If you wonder why I ask this, it's because of the various posts stating that he is. Due to the proof and realistic facts to prove it, I can't deny it entirely.
I'm a Twilight fan, but I find it easy to take an objective stand-point to understand all points of view.
For any old fashioned girls out there, do you think some of his behaviour is acceptable and justified. Is he protecting Bella and acting on his feelings towards her?
Or do you believe his behaviour is wrong? Would you have wished for Bella to get out of the relationship or talk some sense into Edward?
With your point of view, could you please point out whether or not you are a fan of the series?