sagutin ng tanong na ito

puno kansa alkimiko Tanong

Why exactly do people hate Winry Rockbell so much?

So i've been noticing a lot of hate for this character lately ( mostly from one person ) and am wondering why it's really irritating me.I can't see why people would hate her so much! Oh and please don't comment with a stupid answer about why yuo hate her so much. here's the usual complaints
She's an annoying Mary sue: I don't see what people mean sa pamamagitan ng that. She's not perfect and is a very tough tomboy sometimes.

She's to violent with Ed: umm ever heard of comedic relief people? Riza and Izumi trash/ shoot people and it's funny to other's and there loved sa pamamagitan ng everybody! ( not bashing them i pag-ibig them to).

She cries to much: This is one i hate. The reason she cries is because she has feelings like any normal human being. Episode 22 in Brotherhood shows that. Her character is a very well developed one in my opinion.

She got with ed and doesn't deserve him: ohhhh boy with this complaint. Now there are normally two types of people who use this complaint: crazed yaoi tagahanga girls or Edward fangirls who are delusional and want him
Yaoi fangirls: get over it Roy and Ed don't think of each other in that way i really don't care what you believe it's a crazy crack paring like L and Light! Not bashing all yaoi fangirls but you take ti to far most of the time.
Edward fangirls: I admit i'm one but at least i know Ed's a fictional character! and because of this wouldn't you want him to get with someone and be happy?

She's a slut: where did this come from? not in either series has Winry been seen having affections for madami thne one character romantically and has never had a boy friend before Ed.

Now Winry isn't my paborito character and i do have things i dislike about her myself: She can be a bit to much sometimes but that's part of her charm i guess. So what do you think? if you pag-ibig her why? if you hate her why? ( but make the reasons good at least)

 Why exactly do people hate Winry Rockbell so much?
*
How in **** is Winry a whore?!All they ever shown is her taking off her shirt(when she didn't know Ed was there) but we all change clothes right?And then her in the bath.But we all take showers and baths and it wasn't like she was doing this so Ed and Al could watch. Plus, she was only ever romantically involved with Ed, nobody else.
Pandora4ster posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
LOL Winry isn't a whore for wearing a black tuktok that reveals her stomach around her house. Slut is a disgusting term anyway.
kyoukos posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Winry is awesome!
ravissa posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I pag-ibig her!
ravissa posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
 Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

puno kansa alkimiko  pinakamahusay na sagot

CorriNova said:
Well, please hear me out on why I and most people hate her. I am not a crazed Ed fan-girl, and I am not into yaoi. In fact, if I were obsessed with a character, it would be Greed/Ling.
She is Whinny. Ed and Winry both had their parents killed, yes. However, Winry did not get any body part or anything else taken from her. Also, they died when Winry was about 2, so she couldn't have remembered enough about it. Ed and Al, however, got their body parts removed from them, and also were old enough to realize what had happened. You have to agree that she is capricious, she goes from happy to angry in 1 second.

She treats Ed horribly. She shows that she loves him, and then tries to kill him with a wrench. In the first series, she makes Ed buy her things. Ed gets a load of money when he uses alchemy, and Winry steals it. She steals it because the automail that SHE created wasn't good enough to beat the guy in an arm wrestle. How is that Ed's fault?

She is a slut. I think that you misunderstand what a slut is. She either has a black bra on, or an extremely short palda on. I did a comparison and the school uniform palda is longer than her daily wear.

She cries too much. Yeah, if she cared about Ed so much, why did she do so many horrid things to him? She cries for no reason, its annoying. She obviously doesn't think that Ed can handle on his own.

Winry is a whore. At first she showed madami of a liking towards Ed. When she realized that he didn't like her like that, she went straight to Alphonse.

She doesn't deserve him. Yes, I agree that Ed should be happy. But Winry did what? Screw up multiple times on fixing his arm? Yell at him? Throw metal objects at him? Yes

Riza and Izumi have a reason to hurt people. They hate them. Riza is in the military, when she kills people it isn't comical relief, its ipinapakita that she is strong. Izumi does beat up Ed, because she is his teacher, she wants to make him stronger. Winry simply hurts Ed because he has other things to do than to always hang out with Winry.

Does she not realize that Ed has to kill people, and things?
I mean, he is out killing sins of alchemy and Winry just wants him to hang out with her? Is she that stupid?


That's all I can think of right now. This is why I hate Winry Rockbell

select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
she does not go to Al at all in either series. She does not try to "kill" ed with her wrench only hurt him a bit, and ti's funny. also "she was only 2 when her parents died" no she was the same age as ed and al when Trisha died
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Wait what? She goes from Ed to Al? Did I miss something from the the original anime and Brotherhood or the manga? Or are you trolling because if you are, it makes people think you havent seen the anime or read the manga and you are just here to troll and blather nonsense. Winry never goes to Al. Mei would surely go into yandere mode if she did. Winry falls in pag-ibig with Ed throughout the series. Also, most of your complaints about Winry are atrocious.
Sinister9 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I know I'm probably late for this debate, but your sagot for this bugged me. a LOT. She's whinny? Okay. I understand this one, but in the first series she loses her parents not long before Ed and Al Nawawala their mother. In Brotherhood, if you listen to English Dub, at one point AFTER their mom dies, Ed is teasing Winry about being a cry baby every time her parents leave. She treats Ed horribly? She's bashing him for being an idiot, she's a bit tempermental too, especially when it comes to her childhood friends. Saying Winry is abusive to Ed is like saying (Soul Eater refrences) Maka is abusive to Soul. A slut? If you don't happen to notice, part of her palda is covered sa pamamagitan ng her shirt. She also works with metal, and also worked in a very warm climate in Rush Valley. She cries too much? I think I'd cry a lot if my two closes childhood mga kaibigan A. Came to my door as a suit of empty armor and/or missing limbs and close to bleeding to death. And B. Goes off on an adventure and comes back for repairs like every week. Ed's a hard-headed idiot so he needs a bashing every now and again. Winry cries because Al can't and Ed refuses to. A whore. A WHORE. Are you serious? Has Winry EVER done ANYTHING to ipakita ANY attraction to ANYONE other than Ed that I had missed? Winry HANGS OUT with other guys, talks with Al about her feeling because he's madami sympathetic than Ed seems to show. So, I don't know WHERE you got that Winry is a whore. She doesn't desrve him? Seroiusly man? She screwed up ONCE and that saved Ed from getting even madami screwed over than he already was. She cried for them. She cared for them while Ed moped ovr his faliure at bringing their mother back and Al losing his body. She gave Ed prosthetics so he could stand again. They aren't the most ideal couple in the book, but they still belong together. Winry isn't the BEST character, but she doesn't deserve all the hate people give.
fawnkityoutube1 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Sagot

egyptprincess7 said:
Apparently,it's because she get's in the way of RoyEd. Even though,that pairing won't happen. Another reason is,she's Ed's pag-ibig interest. Personally,I like Winry. She's a developed character,and you have to admit. It was very sad when her parents died,and I remember when she pointed that gun at Scar. *Sigh* I agree with you though,she can be a bit too much at times.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Lol your icon is Winry. Epic coincidence.
wantadog posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
i didn't mean it in a bad way really it's pretty funny! and yesh she's so developed especially in Brotherhood
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
NO...not my take at all.
Sinna_Hime_chan posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
well then....that's your opinion
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
SBTrulz said:
I think Winry's awesome. She's a well-developed character. I can't see any reason to hate her.
And yesssss, RoyEd makes no sense! EdWin for the win!!! ;D
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
kvang said:
I don't hate Winry. (I pag-ibig it when she pulls out her trusty wrench) but I guess you're right she can be a bit too much. One of my pet peeves about anime is that it's always the girl who crys too much and have to get rescued or be saved or protected. And Winry tends to cry alot. I think madami anime girls should be like Mira Olivier Armstrong or at least Haruhi.
select as best answer
 I don't hate Winry. (I pag-ibig it when she pulls out her trusty wrench) but I guess you're right she can be a bit too much. One of my pet peeves about anime is that it's always the girl who crys too much and have to get rescued or be saved or protected. And Winry tends to cry alot. I think madami anime girls should be like Mira Olivier Armstrong or at least Haruhi.
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
well from what i've seen she cried at a very understandable time. also she doesn't seem to get kidnapped a lot or whatever i mena she's not orihime inoue! okay...i guess i agree with you about madami girls being like Oliver and Riza though
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
You do realize she has cried on sad moments, right?
pumpkinqueen posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Same reason why I hate Rose from FMA and Kagome from Inuyasha, Sakura in the beginning of the story from Naruto, Maka from Soul Eater. Misa from deathnote, There is a lot madami though
CorriNova posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Brotherhood65 said:
I don't like her because she is useless, she gets in peoples way and annoys the heck out of me. Yes, I know she fixes Ed's arm, but there are so many people out there that can do that too! This is my opinion! :) I like her sometimes, cuz shes funny...
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
A bit late, but how can she be useless, when she creates auto-mail for people who Nawawala their limbs and is maybe even one of the better specialists out there (there may be many more, but what would it be if there were only a few of them in the entire world. All engineers are needed). And people seem to forget about the time when she delivered a baby all sa pamamagitan ng herself. Back then she was the most useful person. Her strength is not physical skills, but her ability to help and heal people. Everyone has their own place in the story and Winry plays her imho almost if not perfectly.
EmiKoizumi posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Katherine1517 said:
Personally, I loved Winry Rockbell's character and her quirks as one as she is my segundo paborito female character from both FMA and Brotherhood (First is Lan Fan).

I think some people dislike her because they find her to be annoying, stupid and useless. In my opinion, she's not at all. Others may dislike her because they only view her as a pag-ibig interest for Ed as well as the fact that she gets in the way of other shippings with Ed. I find that to be a completely stupid reasoning to dislike a character to be honest.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Exactly she's not bad at all
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
wantadog said:
I like her! She's an awesome character. She's definitely in my tuktok 20 paborito anime girls. Not quite in my tuktok 10, but still very high.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
pumpkinqueen said:
My guess is because people are very crazy and biased. Because she is Edward's pag-ibig interest and they get married. All the nut RoyEd fans hate her because she 'gets in the way' of the pairing. But seriously, there is nothing to get in the way of.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I hate when people hate a character simply because of shipping.
zanhar1 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
exactly it's not a reason to hate someone!
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
ixAthena said:
People want RoyEd, even though that will never ever happen. To me, she's alright but I see her crying in almost every episode.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
no NOT all people... personal Ed?Me is gets my vote
Sinna_Hime_chan posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Sinna_Hime_chan said:
I'm sorry- I did not read through your whole list. I have my opinion and people do. I generally do not like overly emotional female characters because in real life they annoy me.

I see no need for meaness, for whininess, and when she got mad when there was all that commotion and drama in her room and Ed was eating a sandwich-lol. I would have thrown the dude on the kama and slammed the door! (Not literally maybe at that point), I would have been angry, maybe, and annoyed at so many people in my room but I don't explode like that. I saw nothing wrong with Ed's answer for her to get so mad. She should have been happy. So I don't like it.

I don't like any lead female char who I think I would be better in that role, lol - and that accounts for a lot I am afriad, so IF that sagot your question. I don't ship. I want ME in the role with the guy I like -that only makes sense, why would I ever in a million years consider anyone else with someone I like? 'not happening in fangirl land (my head), and not someone who acts stupid sometimes in these characters. It makes them who they are- I understand, but sometimes I don't like that aspect/s of who they are.
select as best answer
 I'm sorry- I did not read through your whole list. I have my opinion and people do. I generally do not like overly emotional female characters because in real life they annoy me. I see no need for meaness, for whininess, and when she got mad when there was all that commotion and drama in her room and Ed was eating a sandwich-lol. I would have thrown the dude on the kama and slammed the door! (Not literally maybe at that point), I would have been angry, maybe, and annoyed at so many people in my room but I don't explode like that. I saw nothing wrong with Ed's answer for her to get so mad. She should have been happy. So I don't like it. I don't like any lead female char who I think I would be better in that role, lol - and that accounts for a lot I am afriad, so IF that sagot your question. I don't ship. I want ME in the role with the guy I like -that only makes sense, why would I ever in a million years consider anyone else with someone I like? 'not happening in fangirl land (my head), and not someone who acts stupid sometimes in these characters. It makes them who they are- I understand, but sometimes I don't like that aspect/s of who they are.
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I don't hate her at all, and at least she is a strong person, I like that, she is cute/pretty, and has a good personality in other ways... so there is madami to like than dislike. I like her as a character.
Sinna_Hime_chan posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Um....because the character is fictional and you're never in a million years going to be with them, so you want the best character for them. So you want a miss buttercup character, with no emotions at all?
pumpkinqueen posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
How is she a slut?It's just the way she dresses.Mechanics work with grease, so if she was wearing a lot of clothes she'd have grease and oil stains everywhere!P.S. she has a right to throw hard ojects cause she only whines and throws shit when other people are being bitches.
Pandora4ster posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
alexismanga said:
She is to soft. She shouldn't be able to survive in Ed's and Al's world
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
i don't really see her as soft ( ever see her with a wrench XD) and besides a persons value isn't based on strength
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
That is true but why doesn't she do something about it when the guys ignore her and keep her out of their world
alexismanga posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
She's not a slut Edwin's now incest,and don't call kalabasa names
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
RobinFan360 said:
I've heard people say she's too violent.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
She's not to violent to me...
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I don't think she is either but they don't like how she hits Ed with a wrench everytime XD
RobinFan360 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
You hitting people with wrenches is comic relief.you should see what izumi does to the guys in manga format.that crosses the line from comic relief to abusive!
Pandora4ster posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
zanhar1 said:
I personally don't like her because I think she's a boring character no offense.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
of course i'm not going to take offense lol. yeah she's nit my fave either i just don't think she deserves all the hate she gets
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I say no offense for those who go off on you for expressing your opinion. You don't seem like that kind of person. I know what you mean; I don't like her but I don't hate her. There are characters *coughTuckercough* who deserve it more.
zanhar1 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Oh yes Tucker needs to burn in hell for what he did
Alchemistlover posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
virjoo said:
i havent read the whole series but it might be because her character seems like the typical bossy annoying shonen girl who fights with the main character and then gets together with him. i never disliked her though, she's ok.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
5abunnylover said:
Personally, I think Winry is a great character. Unlike a lot of main girls in anime, Kana from Nura Rise of the Yokai Clan as an example, Winry doesn't really depend on Ed too much, only when she knows he is going to save her. She is normally too proud to ask for help, so when she does its not exactly 'Damsel In Distress', madami like 'Oh My God I'm Going to Die. Please Help me Edward!!' Also, she's gorgeous. Me and my sister have agreed that Riza and Winry are beautiful. Enough Said.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
ktopazski said:
I know that whatever I say, EdxWinry fans are going to object. I understand the feeling. Besides, I'm pretty sure my reasons have already been stated sa pamamagitan ng other people. So I'll just say that I generally do not like 'weak' anime characters, especially girls. Winry might have had her strong moments, but I just get the feeling that she can't let go of her past. I realize that her parents died, but she had it way better than Ed and Al. Their dad abandoned their family, so they both felt a sense of abandonment and hatred towards their father. Their mother also died when Ed was 9 and Al was 8 (I believe), unlike how Winry's parents died when she was 2. At least she didn't know that her dad had abandoned her family and her mother had suffered for many years due to an illness and had just up and died. She also didn't attempt to bring her mother back and lose an arm and a leg (and for Al, an entire body) for her efforts, and end up having a very painful procedure done to acquire two fake, mechanical limbs (or in Al's case, a body made of armor). And yet, Winry still cries all the time. Now, I'm not saying there was no reason for her to cry. I'm just saying she couldn't have possibly suffered as much as Al and Ed, who had the strength to ilipat on and help other people along their way. Winry can be kind at times, but who takes someone's mind off something sa pamamagitan ng making them buy you a truckload of expensive equipment?
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
...again people, get your facts straight, her parents did NOT die when she was 2. She was talking and crying at the mesa about their death, she clearly was 2 years old. And don't you dare put a price on someone's paining, like it is a contest. Nobody can 'suffer' madami then the other. WInry Nawawala her parents, Edward and Al did too, they both had Granny to take care of them. Edward and Al left on a dangerous journey, leaving Winry alone to worry. She suffered just as much as they did.
pumpkinqueen posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Yeah she did! Think about her encounters with scar and the time she found out he killed her parents!Plus winry had to constantly worry about ed and al while they are completely oblivious that she is worried and just keep on hurting themselves!
Pandora4ster posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Torento said:
There are some things I bash a lot not because they're terrible but because they're the first thing that comes to mind when I think of mediocre such as Foreigner as a rock and roll group. Anyway I bash Winry a lot myself, but I wouldn't say she's a terrrible character. My issues with Winry are she gets way too much screen time for not being such a great character. Sure she's upbeat, tomboyish (a trait I absolutely love, however, with Winry this is not as much as some other characters in Full Metal Alchemist, I hate feminism, but I pag-ibig that there are many women in this anime who can kick a**) and attractive. I actually sinabi to my friend while we finished watching the series that one thing Winry had going for her was a very well done character design. However, all the time Winry had on screen could've been cut down and ibingiay to some better, madami deserving characters who I would have loved to have seen better developed such as Maria Ross. She was a phenomenal character that I wish had been ibingiay much madami screen time. Between her and Winry, I would definitely choose Maria. Other female characters that were better than Winry in my opinion were Riza Hawkeye, Olivier Armstrong (not many people liked her either because she was too aggressive, but I liked her) Izumi Curtis, Lan tagahanga (biggest piece of jailbait I've ever seen, d***...) Martel and Paninya. Now a couple of the characters I just listed were killed off or minor and needed no madami development, but the first four all could have had madami screen time and I would've loved to have seen it.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
What?! Nobody should hate Winry!
AidenTheSaiyan posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
winry was developed enough ur right, but i still like her
Pandora4ster posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
winry was developed enough ur right,but i still like her
Pandora4ster posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
AidenTheSaiyan said:
I do not hate Winry, she is awesome!!!
Other than Ed and Al, Winry is my fave character.
Yeah, she can be a little too rough sometimes, but that is what makes her Winry X3 Nobody should hate Winry, there is no reason at all to hate her. She is a very sweet girl, and she really cares for everybody.
Plus, I am a big EdxWin fan. I will always like Winry!
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
npetruescu said:
Winry is sa pamamagitan ng far one of my paborito characters in Fullmetal. The reason being that she seems alive as if a real person. If a real girl wanted to shoot someone then didn't I am pretty sure that they would cry too.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Livingshadow said:
I think the main reason why people hated winry is because how she was portrayed. You can't even say she became a better person through character development because really we weren't shown any. all we were basically shown is:
1. she cares for the brothers
2. she's an auto-mail prodigy
3. she can be really emotional...aka she cries alot.
4. she can be stubborn and selfish
5. she's abusive towards edward and hits him alot.
I can go on, but you see my point. you can argue and say 'she's Nawawala her parents. thats why she's emotional' or 'because she's an automail prodigy. she's perfect for Edward'...no offence but Ed and Al also Nawawala their parents and I know this sounds cold...they actually saw their parent die and was practically abandoned sa pamamagitan ng the other. And for her being an automail prodigy...just because she's good at fixing metal limbs, doesn't make her perfect for edward...she still charges him each time it breaks and hits him each time it happens. he can easily go elsewhere for new limbs.
Because of how she acted. people started to hate her character. and PLEASE don't say her pagganap abusive is for comic relief. it wasn't even funny and if the rolls were reversed and he was hitting/beating her up, aka a man hitting a woman.
...I can bet you no one would be laughing. its wrong a character should be liked, just because they hurt others.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
No, she is perfect for Edward because they understand each other and they are childhood friends, the whole series shows why they are perfect together. She creator shows you that enough before they end up together. And stop the abusive junk, she is no way abusive to him. She doesn't leave him broken or bleeding for god sakes, it is NO different then how of any of the other female characters act. Izumi hits Edward and Al ALL the time. Edward needs a good hit with a wrench now and then, because he acts reckless and stupid, he needs to be set straight. She is not really emotional, she is NORMAL, people cry when they are sad and she cries on time any normal people WOULD cry. Freakin meeting the person who KILLED your parents, that is overreacting? Seriously, stop with the excuses already.
pumpkinqueen posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
And WAIT, what about EDWARD with his short rants? He hits people and attacks them and spins them around. THAT is hurting someone madami then Winry. Do YOU like him? Saying it's 'wrong' to like Edward?
pumpkinqueen posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
The truth is indeed a beautiful thing! I agree with you!
Sinister9 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
jacobpilcher said:
winry's fucking amazing
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
ImAnEasel said:
I don't really hate her or pag-ibig her. Well, I quite like her. Then again, I am in the PROCESS of watching FMA, I haven't finished it, yet... maybe there will be a reason for me to change my mind in the future... but for now, she seems okay. =^_^=
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I already told you. I don't lie. :)
ImAnEasel posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
wooodbury88 said:
ok so winry isnt my favourite character but why hate her, she is a good character and shes allowed to cry about herr dead parents!! she does have her faults but she doesnt deserve to be hated.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
shadowcat22 said:
I don't "hate her" hate is a very strong word, I just dislike her. She's shown as a typical damsel in distress girl when compared to ed and al can't really fend for herself. ed and her don't seem like a very good match. She cries alot, and is just... a baby. if she were shown stronger, i would like her more.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Cryogenic said:
I've watched all the episodes of full metal alchemist and brotherhood. I've also watched both pelikula and I don't hate Winry at all. If you watch as much anime and read as much manga as I do (p.s. that doesn't make me a nerd, I actually do have a life) then you'd realize that certain characters act a certain way for a reason. In my opinion Winry played her part in FMA. This is what I believe: she was there to be the part of the 'pain' that most of the characters had, but not much of them expressed. And YES, she cares for others, is that so wrong? Does that really make her soft? In an anime/manga that already had so much strong characters she was a great placement. I mean I for one pag-ibig an anime with all hard-asses, but it still needs a few characters to remind you that the people in the anime still generally have emotions. And for the pag-ibig of god will you all stop calling her a slut or a whore just because you can't find the proper way to express yourselves. I swear pagbaba some of the comments made me laugh because it sounded just like a bunch of high-school girls talking and bashing on another girl. Oh and about her constantly hitting Ed; I thought that was hilarious. If your still not convinced that its for comedy just look up Nami in One Piece, or Chi Chi in DBZ; case closed. And one madami thing, stop trying to put logical situations in anime. Its anime, shit can happen that defies logic. Like for instance, Winry beats the shit out of Ed with a wrench and he survives, why, because its a fucking anime thats why.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Sinister9 said:
This answer is prettyy long so I'm gonna divide it into parts. read comments for rest.

Winry isn't isn't one of those annoying as ****, irritating, super-tsundere or deredere girls that I loathe with all my being. Yeah, she does bonk Ed and Al on the head with her handy-dandy wrench (hey, they do deserve it sometime, when things get out of hand. And if that is annoying, you should see how Louise treats her "future-hubby" in Zero no Tsukamia. No. How MOST girls tend to treat their future husbands.) And besides, ever heard of comedic effect? Like in Soul Eater when Maka bashes Soul's head with a book, or in Clannad when Kyou throws dictionaries at Sunohara. I can go on and on! Its for comedy, and to make people laugh! Hiromu Arakawa even claims this in a Q & A blog I found not so long ago. She wanted FMA to focus a lot on comedy and the main story plot, not too much on sadness or tragedy.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
And then there's the fact that she cries a lot. Um. No she doesnt. Not in every episode she's in. It is true she gets emotional and she hates the fact that Ed and Al risk their lives everytime, but is that something to bash her about?? She has every right to feel emotional pain and worry her asno off for her two closest childhood friends. And she had her parents taken from her when she was around Ed's age for the pag-ibig of all good things. She was waiting for them to come back like they promised her! Why is it annoying of she cries for the people she cares about? If you finally found your parent's murderer and had the power to avenge their deaths in your hands, but came to a powerful realization tthat you couldn't land the finishing blow, because it wouldn't bring your parent's back, and they wouldn't have wanted you to murder someone, how would you feel?
Sinister9 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Lastly, probably the main reason why so many fangirls dislike Winry. is because. thats correct! SHE GETS ON THE WAY OF EDROY. Okay before some looney fangirl gets offended and is about to have a puso attack and bashes me in the comemnts for this, ED AND ROY WERE NEVER MEANT TO BE WITH EACH OTHER. Not in Canon, but definitely in fanon. I don't really like most of the fandom today anyway since they're full of crazy fangirls/fanboys. And no, I am not saying this because I dislike yaoi or shonen-ai. Of the very few yaoi pairings I like, Elliot and Leo from Pandora Hearts are my favorite. I support them since they are very close to each other and understand one another better than anyone else. So no, I don't dislike yaoi. But there are limits. Age limits, for example. I don't care if people are a few years a part, hell I don't care if they're like 9 years a part, but Ed and Roy are like 15-20 years age different! That's pedophillia, considering the fact that Ed was 12 (now 15) and Roy is in his twenties. He's nearly thirty. In Junjou Romantica, Misaki is 18 (or 19) at first and Usagi is 26 (I think) That's only 8 years apart. I see nothing wrong with that. But 15. Ed would be in his freshman taon on high-school and Roy would be a.. well, a guy who is past highschool and college. And is there any hint that they're into the same sex? And please don't say something like "well they were fighting alongside each other" or "they came face-to-face" or any of that bull. That does NOT mean they have ANYTHING going on whatsoever. That should be common sense. mabangis na kabayo is Ed's commanding officer and the Colonel, so there are such situations involving when they are "face-to-face" or whatever. That beings said, I merely see Roy mabangis na kabayo and Ed Elric as father-son or older bro and little bro. Or just friends. Or simply Colonel and soldier. And isn't is quite obvious in the manga and Brotherhood that Roy and Riza are closer to each other than anyone else? Sure they don't halik (unfortunately...) or blush around each other, but they are always there for each other. (Like Elliot and Leo) Just read the manga or watch Brotherhood is you haven't already. They don't confess they like each other, but neither do Elliot and Leo or Ciel and Sebastian, or Rukia and Ichigo. But fans still live them! That's all. I've been wanting to let out everything I've felt for a while, and I finally have. Hope no one got offended... It comes to ipakita how crazy fandom can be, anime or not.
Sinister9 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
fhghu said:
I personally pag-ibig Winry, so I don't really understand all the hate. I don't ship EdWin, but that doesn't mean I hate Winry. I actually ship her with other characters, so....XD
I always get annoyed when people hate a character because they ended up with a certain character. Why can't you just focus on their personality? Their character development? Why not any of that? When people bash her for crying, it really annoys me. What's wrong with Winry crying for Ed and Al? Like she said, those two don't, so she's crying for them. I would cry too if my best mga kaibigan were going through what Ed and Al went through. And I hate when people call her useless. She's Ed's automail mechanic! She's the one constantly fixing his automail. Give her some credit. I also think she is really funny too, and is a really good friend to both Ed and Al. She's one of my paborito anime girls, so I don't like to see her hated on.
select as best answer
 I personally pag-ibig Winry, so I don't really understand all the hate. I don't ship EdWin, but that doesn't mean I hate Winry. I actually ship her with other characters, so....XD I always get annoyed when people hate a character because they ended up with a certain character. Why can't you just focus on their personality? Their character development? Why not any of that? When people bash her for crying, it really annoys me. What's wrong with Winry crying for Ed and Al? Like she said, those two don't, so she's crying for them. I would cry too if my best mga kaibigan were going through what Ed and Al went through. And I hate when people call her useless. She's Ed's automail mechanic! She's the one constantly fixing his automail. Give her some credit. I also think she is really funny too, and is a really good friend to both Ed and Al. She's one of my paborito anime girls, so I don't like to see her hated on.
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I agree with you on all of that. I don't mind Winry because she is so independent. I wish I was madami like her, but so far all we have in common is a pag-ibig for engineering. But can we please am owlets the fact that she tried to tell Ed and al that they weren't suffering as much as her because their dad "just left" and could come back but her parents were dead. The comparing made me sad, because al was only trying to point out that they'd all Nawawala people and they were there for her. I thought it was kind of mean of her...
lolihavenoidea posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
alienpenguin said:
I personally ship Roy/Ed. I realize it is implausible but I still do it but I hate Roy/Ed fics that demonize Winry when all she's tried to do is help. She's not perfect but she's a great character.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Animelover723 said:
im probably really late to this pagtatalo also but this really frustrated me
yes i understand all the fangirls opinions and i respect that but just please
the fact that she was called a whore is unacceptable please just cuz she wears revealing clothing is mostly because of her work and a lot of people wear revealing clothing but dont get called sluts or whores even sometimes i wear croptops and revealing clothing but that doesnt mean im a slut ive never even had my first halik yet people dont judge sa pamamagitan ng her appearance and judge sa pamamagitan ng all shes done for the elrics
she gave ed a leg and arm so he could survive she gave him life imagine if he didnt have that arm what wouldve happened oh yea nothing he wouldnt even be able to use alchemy and sa pamamagitan ng the way the fact that she cries is just ipinapakita shes a human being with feelings so shes madami emotional than others. its not like shes crying for no reason im pretty sure i would cry in those situations come on at least ed and als parents werent murdered during a war like seriously im not saying ed and al dont have it hard too believe me they do but so does she while it may not be as bad as the brothers its still hard on her imagine losing your own parents how sad would you be? exactly dont call her whiny either shes a girl deal with it everyone gets whiny so does ed so shut it and deal with it.
also about the wrench get over it come on its there to be funny also you gotta admit ed and al kinda need that im pretty sure i would do the same as winry if i could but i dont wanna kill anybody so oh well. but seriously they need some sense to be knocked into their brains come on they have people to live for might as well remind them of that since they so recklessly risk their lives almost every araw dont you think so
also the fact that she doesnt deserve him oh my god they were obviously meant to be ed and winry are both headstrong and are too dense to realise their feelings although winry figured out before theyre still oblivious about their feelings kinda. just let them be happy together and dont judge them come on if you pag-ibig them let them be happy. you dont have to share your hate for them so publicly how do you think the may-akda would feel if they saw your responses of you hating his characters and his story. im oretty sure hed kinda feel shitty so just be happy you dont have to share the hate so publicly why dont you rant about it to your mga kaibigan or write it down or something but theres no need for you to be so rude about it like that.
and everyone that reads this if you really dont like her and disagree with me please no im not trying to offend you or br rude in any way. and btw i get how you feel the need to just rant about your least paborito characters and everything but just think about what you write too ok? and anyone who doesnt like my punctuation and spelling and grammer please forgive me its 3:35 am over here so im a bit out of it. i pag-ibig everyone but please mind the judging a bit alright?
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
ravissa said:
Lol, I know I'm late for this pagtatalo but better late then never! xD.
As for what you said, I couldn't have sinabi it any better, ALL of the reasons to hate Winry are terrible and make no real sense.
To me, Winry is an awesome characters, she's strong, beautiful, funny and she's always been there for Edward and Alphonse, supporting them, worrying for them, loving them and she turned out to be very useful to them especially to Ed.

I wish I had a friend like her, like for real!

She's not perfect and, yes, she has feelings because well, SHE IS HUMAN!
It's okay to cry OMG! Ed cries alot too, and so did most of the characters through the show. + As an orphan she remains a very good and evolving character....Like seriously, do you people know what real orphans are like? Cuz I do, (not bashing them but) orphans can be very depressed, scared and even revengeful, but Winry is strong and through out the show, she is always ready to help!

And seriously...yaoi between Edward and Roy? Really?
I pag-ibig yaoi, but I never saw this one coming, I had no idea people actually invented stuff between Ed and Roy,they don't see each other in that way. If people are ready to hate Winry because they ship Edward and Roy...the world is doomed.
And those who hate Winry because they pag-ibig Ed (the crazy Ed fangirls)... It's sad but Ed is a fictional character, he doesn't exist in real life, you can't be with him, so let him enjoy his happiness with the awesome Winry. Jeez

And lastly...Winry, a whore? WHAT THE HECK?! Seriously.
She is a sweet girl that is only involved romantically with Edward + People have the right to be sexy! Envy wears revealing cloths, Lust wears...well hum *cough cough*, she's very erotic looking hum...etc.... Even Gluttony wears tight cloths (it's horrible but true)
So yeah, what Winry wears is fine too even though it's showy+ there is nothing madami beautiful then a confident woman in her body!


Yeppies, so, yeah, everything @AlchemistLover says is true! And there's really no legit reason to actually hate Winry, she's awesome to the show, and a great person, useful, beautiful, funny and perfect for Ed. Sh's my fav female of the show, and Ed, being my fav male (duh); they go together perfect! Voila!
select as best answer
 Lol, I know I'm late for this pagtatalo but better late then never! xD. As for what you said, I couldn't have sinabi it any better, ALL of the reasons to hate Winry are terrible and make no real sense. To me, Winry is an awesome characters, she's strong, beautiful, funny and she's always been there for Edward and Alphonse, supporting them, worrying for them, loving them and she turned out to be very useful to them especially to Ed. I wish I had a friend like her, like for real! She's not perfect and, yes, she has feelings because well, SHE IS HUMAN! It's okay to cry OMG! Ed cries alot too, and so did most of the characters through the show. + As an orphan she remains a very good and evolving character....Like seriously, do you people know what real orphans are like? Cuz I do, (not bashing them but) orphans can be very depressed, scared and even revengeful, but Winry is strong and through out the show, she is always ready to help! And seriously...yaoi between Edward and Roy? Really? I pag-ibig yaoi, but I never saw this one coming, I had no idea people actually invented stuff between Ed and Roy,they don't see each other in that way. If people are ready to hate Winry because they ship Edward and Roy...the world is doomed. And those who hate Winry because they pag-ibig Ed (the crazy Ed fangirls)... It's sad but Ed is a fictional character, he doesn't exist in real life, you can't be with him, so let him enjoy his happiness with the awesome Winry. Jeez And lastly...Winry, a whore? WHAT THE HECK?! Seriously. She is a sweet girl that is only involved romantically with Edward + People have the right to be sexy! Envy wears revealing cloths, Lust wears...well hum *cough cough*, she's very erotic looking hum...etc.... Even Gluttony wears tight cloths (it's horrible but true) So yeah, what Winry wears is fine too even though it's showy+ there is nothing madami beautiful then a confident woman in her body! Yeppies, so, yeah, everything @AlchemistLover says is true! And there's really no legit reason to actually hate Winry, she's awesome to the show, and a great person, useful, beautiful, funny and perfect for Ed. Sh's my fav female of the show, and Ed, being my fav male (duh); they go together perfect! Voila!
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I agree with you on all of that, but can we just stop and think about the time she tried to tell Ed and al that she was suffering madami than they were because her parents were dead and their dad "just left"? That was pretty mean. But other than that I pag-ibig her! Girl power and all haha. I like that I'm not the only girl
lolihavenoidea posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Just saying the comparing was unfair because al was just trying to tell her he knew what it was liek to slows someone important to you and that he would be there for her and she shot him down
lolihavenoidea posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
@lolihavenoidea you are right about that, she did do dumb thing, but then again,all of the character did stupid things at some point
ravissa posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
jasoncorrosive1 said:
I think she's a great character, super cute. Not sure about this "slut" thing, but I know one thing, I pag-ibig when she is in that short black miniskirt, get a chubby every time...and I don't always when I see drawings.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
cookie466 said:
I hate Winry, Edwin I always thought they had like a bro sis relationship but you know they're fictional and if that's who the writers paired him with you know like whatever. But the reason's I hate winry

1 I pag-ibig female characters but she's a little to strong. She's always beating up someone with a wrench. I get it's comic relief and sometimes Ed and Al do deserve it but a book, matunog na halik em in the head but a wrench is a little over the tuktok as in bordering on abuse. Maria Ross slapped Ed, Riza's shot at him but they never hit him with a heavy metal object in the head.

2 She's always either crying or angry. She's human people have emotions but she can't control hers and it makes her seem whiny and bratty.

3 I get she cares about Ed and Al but to me she just seems kinda bossy and doesn't give them their puwang and their privacy like when she opened the pocket watch or when she blew up cause they kept secrets from her. Everybody has secrets.

So yeah please no hate, I respect everybody's opinion so respect mine you can say what you gotta say just don't go cursing me or being rude cause I don't like a fictional character.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I don't hate her, but I do agree with the points you made.
Kuro_Hyou666 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
lolihavenoidea said:
Alright so i don't hate Winry. She's cool, but she was a little annoying at times. pangkalahatang she was interesting but she was a little cruel, too. My main complaints are: 1) she went straight from whining she was bored and telling the Al and Ed their present sucked (which was kind of mean) to crying about how scary it was. (And making them feel bad)I guess that ain't much of an argument caz alchemy is some pretty freaky stuff. 2) when her parents died she basically told Ed and al that they were lucky their father left them caz at least he "could come back." Obviously she didn't understand that when people choose to leave and make their family suffer for it they don't USUALLY INTEND TO COME BACK. The point was all three of them had Nawawala parents and it hurt equally. It was an uncalled for comment, especially when al was trying to comfort her. And I could be wrong, but I don't think she ever apologized for it. Finally 3) her voice annoyed me when she freaked out over the engineering stuff when she made Ed buy all that stuff for her when she first came to visit them after Ed became a state alchemist. (Excuse my bad grammar) And she was oblivious when he (subtly) wanted her to stop buying things with his money. (But I think he did offer, so it was mostly his fault) anyways it bothered me that she didn't notice/care. Also, she absolutely SQUEALED over a micrometer. Don't get me wrong, I'm a girl and i take engineering courses at school- so I'm into it too, but I don't think being able to accurately measure parts deserved that amount of excitement. Personally, I find dimensioning to be the most boring thing I've ever done... But to each his (her) own, no? If you bothered to read this far, thanks haha. I'm probably over analyzing this considering it's just one story, but that's just my engineer side isn't it? So basically; if winry and Ed are happy together: madami power to them. I'm glad they're a good match. I honestly didn't pag-ibig Winry, but pangkalahatang she's pretty awesome when you get past the mean/ annoying things she's done. Nobody's perfect right?
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
true xD
ravissa posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
yolobro79 said:
I like her because to me she's entertaining and the other reason is she is pretty so everyone of you haters that just come up with these lame excuses and reasons why you hate her you can just SHUT UP AND DEAL WITH IT did you really waste all your time coming up with lame excuses?
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
waffle_turd said:
I still ship WinrAl (Winry x Al :P ) and so the reason I hate her is because she is with mah boi Ed and not her soul mate.
select as best answer
posted 5 months ago 
Kibahina96 said:
Because they're jealous that shes with Ed
select as best answer
posted 4 months ago 
next question »