Newcomers Question: Who do you think is most disposable in the group. Rank from Most to least Disposable, why?

Ewwww thats hard all of them are so talented in their different ways…i think it will not be the same if someone is out of the group so no one! ^^

hmm well if I had to make an listahan of who I thought was disposable, it would have to be someone who I thought didnt add anything to the group and there would only be 4 people.

The people who would BE in desposiable is

Jessica-though her voice is great, she doesn't dance as well as she sings so she is out her replacement would be Seohyun, would can sing, dance, and harmonize better with the main singer ie "My heart" part in the Boys

Tiffany-same with Jessica, though her voice has a lower register she has a hard time dancing and Seohyun and Taeyeon have better voices

Yoona- she is just a pretty face that can dance but she can't sing

Sooyoung- not the best dancer and not the best singer, she can be replaced sa pamamagitan ng Sunny or Seohyun who can sing and dance. She is a jack-of-all-trades but masters nothing. She is mostly iffy, because its either her or Hyoyeon
or
Hyoyeon-her style of dancing isn't always cohesive with the rest of the members

Those who would NOT be desposable
Taeyeon-best voice, she really can't go anywhere and her dancing is ok

Seohyun-next best voice that can harmonize and dance

Sunny-well rounded in pag-awit and dancing better aside from Seohyun

Yuri-she can sing and is a fluid dancer which is good and useful and can keep par with the main dancer

Hyoyeon- she can sing ok and her dance talent is something that you really don't want to have competing against you
or
Sooyoung- she can at least keep up with Yuri and can do a better job at pag-awit then Hyoyeon


I don't really want them to be 5 people but it would be better for certain places. Any opinions or thoughts?

The way I see it, to be successful you HAVE to keep Taeyeon, Jessica, and Yoona. The rest all have their pros and cons.

Necessary:

Taeyeon-best singer, huge die-hard fanbase in Asia.

Jessica-second singer, speaks english, very popular.

Yoona-people always forget she is the most popular member. If you get rid of her, you get rid of a large amount of the fansbase. Yoona helped add fame to SNSD because of her earlier pagganap career. And she is perfect at SNSD style dancing.

Inbetween:

Seohyun-most talented member IMO she can sing and dance and is considered to be one of the prettiest in Asia, after Yoona and Yuri. But many people find her personality boring.

Tiffany-speaks english and is considered to be very pretty in America. But she has added many antis because she doesn't know much about Korean culture and she is the worst dancer.

Yuri-adds sex appeal and is a good dancer also considered segundo prettiest in Asia but she doesn't add as much popularity as Yoona, so she can't make up for her not-that-great singing.

Dispensible:

Hyoyeon-she's the best dancer, but let's be honest SNSD could've been popular without her because of Korea's issue with her looks. It's really sad that she can't be appreciated, but it's true. Also, her dancing is meant for madami than cute choreography it's not really her style.

Sooyoung-everything she can do, Yuri and Yoona can do and she's not popular in Asia, which is where SNSD is from.

Sunny-she is the least popular member internationally. And her pag-awit and dancing are very weak live, so she doesn't contribute much. All she is is the "cute" one it's too bad SM couldn't have ibingiay her another angle.

BUT now that they have established a reputation for talent and popularity, it would be stupid to get rid of any one of them, especially since the girls have gotten so close to each other.

Fany, taeyeon, seo, sica, sunny, hyo, yuri, soo and yoona were all not disposable....