Harry Potter Vs. Twilight

sagutin ng tanong na ito

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Tanong

Why are SOME Twilight fans so aggressive about Harry Potter, even going as far as to pick holes out of JK Rowling?

*
@all are you talking abt me??
mr-cullen posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
No, I'm not directing this at any one particular person. Besides, I can't remember you picking holes out of any author.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
 Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Sagot

cassie-1-2-3 said:
Picking out plot holes is a perfectly acceptable thing to do. There's nothing wrong with it, as long as you're trying to be reasonable. (It's easy to tell when people are being reasonable, and when they're being hateful. Usually, if words like "stupid", "Idiotic", "sut", and the like aren't being used, they're most likely not being hateful)

When it comes to mindless bashing, it happens for the same exact reason Harry Potter fans at times mindlessly bash Twilight. We're not different from each other.
(Please don't tell me sme Twilight fans haven't read Harry Potter. Some Harry Potter fans haven't read Twilight. Also, don't give me any made up statistic. There is no statistic in existance that proves how many Twilight fans have read Twilight and vise versa, and unless you know "most Twilight fans" or "most Harry Potter fans", not a single person here knows how many Harry Potter and Twilight fans have read the opposing books)
 select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
What you've sinabi is fine, but the thing is, a lot of twilight fans I've encountered do NOT state why they think Twilight is better than Harry Potter. I'd be perfectly happy to listen to them if they do. Most comments Harry Potter fans have made seem quite logical to me... about twilight containing too much pag-ibig and not enough plot for example, although some harry potter fans simply say, 'because harry potter IS better than twilight'. I'd pag-ibig it if all of you can explain using reasonable reasons why you think Twilight is better, because I truly do not understand. I'll be grateful (i'm not being sarcastic). I'm a dedicated harry potter tagahanga and I often bash twilight, but I ALWAYS offer logical reasons.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
"about twilight containing too much pag-ibig and not enough plot for example" <--- That's not logic, that's someone's opinion tat you agree with. That's the problem, I think. Many say the Twilight reasons are no good and illogical because many are simply opinions, but also fail to realize that the "logical reasons" they so readily accept are just as opinionated and "illogical"
cassie-1-2-3 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
That's fine
cassie-1-2-3 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
bri-marie said:
Why are SOME Harry Potter fans so aggressive about Twilight, even going as far as to pick holes out of Stephenie Meyer?
 select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I wouldn't exactly call it aggression because our reasons are quite logical. And mostly because there are huge holes waiting there to be pecked out
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Hiding 13 comments... click to show.
*
How would you know? I'd say a lot of assumptions are. That's why I'd like to know what you think the flaws are; to see if any twilight fans agree with my assumptions. But well, my request seems to be a waste of time.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
The fact you're assuming I'm a Twilight tagahanga is a pretty big indication from the get-go.
bri-marie posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Jamie_Blue said:
Same reason some Harry Potter fans try to bash Twilight. Maybe they just don't like it.
 select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
But some twilight fans haven't even read harry potter
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
True. But I still take in to account the opinions of those who haven't read Harry Potter. But I might not take it as seriously as someone who read the books and didn't like it.
Jamie_Blue posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
ebcullen4ever said:
I think the same thing can be sinabi about Harry Potter fans being so aggressive about Twilight and doing the same with Stephenie Meyer.
 select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
But normally, there wouldn't be a need for us to be aggressive because as you can see, harry potter fans are the majority,
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
zanhar1 said:
Some HP fans do the same thing so we can't talk.
 select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
The things we do, the reasons we give are logical. Harry Potter naturally has an advantage over Twilight because JK Rowling made it better. Zanhar1, you can't be suggesting Stephenie Meyer is better than Harry Potter. The Harry Potter books have been written even before I was born, and they're still going popular. The twilight books have just been accepted recently. Already the media is saying twilight is the new harry potter, stephenie meyer is the new rowling. I can't believe it! JK Rowling whose books are world famous, compared to Meyer?! Harry potter is for all audiences because it actually teaches us lessons while twilight is only for teenagers. Because the contents, the love, isn't realistic. Adults who have actually experienced real life, real pag-ibig know this, that's why twilight don't interest them.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I never sinabi anything about either series being madami superior then the other. Superiority is all a matter of opinion anyways. Frankly I believe HP is better but that's just me, and the other fans. I was simply stating that both sides pick out plot holes and both sides have good points and not so good points. No need to make a big deal out of something simple.
zanhar1 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
^lol:) Before I didnt understand what she meant. Im sitting here thinking "When on Earth was Twilight (as in the series) ever mentioned in any of the movies?" Then I read your comment and im like "OHHH!!!" LMAO!
ariba_c posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
mr-cullen said:
i am not at all aggressive about Harry Potter,i just hate if hp fans insult twilight for no reason......

i have posted artikulo against twilight also
 select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I'm not saying you're agressive, don't worry. But I was thinking...it is possible to open a pagtatalo page where users can give very logical reasons supporting both sides and criticising the other? Just an idea...
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
^That's actually been tried before. (It was on a pagtitip. a while ago.) But nobody really participated, and it died off. You could paghahanap for the pagtitip. and see if you could bring it back. It'd look myself, but I'm on my iPod and searching for things is a pain.
bri-marie posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
oh, poor you. Okay.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I really do want such a pagtatalo and want to start one. Maybe starting a new one would be easier rather than trying to bring an old one back...
ariba_c posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!