sagutin ng tanong na ito

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Tanong

I need reasons for why Harry Potter is better than Twilight urgently! For a speech!

Twihards, please do not take this tanong as a personal insult. This is actually for a school project thing - well, madami precisely a speech project. I'd like detailed sagot backed up sa pamamagitan ng very convincing supporting facts. I don't want people arguing. I just need Twilight's faults for a persuasive speech. I don't exactly want anything like that 'Dumb Bampira Sparkle' thing. Help from Twihards will be much appreciated too! And please hurry and post up the sagot because my teacher will soon be up my doorstep, demanding my unfinished speech. Thank you, everybody!
*
Yes, sorry. Only the books. If I talk about the pelikula too, there's no way it'll all fit into a three minuto speech.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Wait, are we only talking about the books here?
Mrs-X posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
 Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Sagot

graystone said:
1) Harry Potter series has realistic characters with vibrant personalities and they are very well described. Although, twilight is not void of interesting characters, they never rise to the surface and their history is poorly described.
2)Although, some may sum up Harry Potter as "chilidish tale about a teenage boy killing an evil wizard", it has proved to be much madami than that. It is rich in plot depth, character development. In twilight series, although the theme is eye-catching, the characters are plain, poorly developed and clearly two-dimensional.
3)Harry Potter is a blend of good values and in every book it brings out the importance of friendship,loyalty, love( parental love, sibling love, roamance, etc), faith in what you believe in, faith in others and last but not the least faith in yourself. Twilight just highlights the romantic aspect and plays down many other values.
4)Harry Potter is read my a wide range of age group because it's not entirely based on romance. Twilight is mostly read sa pamamagitan ng teenage girls, and although there may be other age groups it is less in propotion.
5)On a literary note too, Harry Potter series triumphs over the twilight series. The descriptions are madami natural and seem effortless from the part of the writer while in twilight the simplest of things is made into complex knots.
6)In Harry Potter,no statement mentioned sa pamamagitan ng the writer have been left unexplained. In twilight series, every rule laid sa pamamagitan ng the writer had been broken at some point in series.

select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Mrs-X said:
Ok, I'm trying my best here but I'm sorry, I don't think I'll be very helpful...

HP shows a much bigger creativity and research. In HP, JK Rowling didn't only imagine characters, she had to imagine a whole world. Also, the plotline of HP obviously demands madami creativity too if you compare it to Twilight.


Sorry that's the only thing I could think of...


select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
You're welcome and sorry for the bad english xD!
Mrs-X posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Thank you so much. Also, thanks for replying so fast.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Thanks you so much. I'll use them, especially your last one!
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
rere14 said:
well, HP is better for me because not only HP gave you many guidance in life like " anything's possible if you've got enough nerve." (one of my fav quote), the story touch every generation from kids to grandparents, everyone can related to the story and mesmerized sa pamamagitan ng it and one of the best part is we can pass it to our future generation, our kids will be enjoying pagbaba it just like we do, I hope this help your speech :)
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
oh yeah it also gave a perspective how powerful women is, even her looks was a mess (in the book, in the movie emma never look bad) without hermione harry and ron will be loss, a housewife can kill a criminal to protect her children, and even her boyfriend leave her ginny didn't jump from a cliff but became one of DA leader and fight against injustice in her life, the girls in HP are amazing!!!
rere14 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Thanks a million. It helped!
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
that is true. but do you think HP is better than Twiligth? i mean it is a life lesson in HP but also in Twilight
dalilee posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
cunha27 said:
Harry Potter can be enjoyed sa pamamagitan ng a wider audience as most of the books (specially the earlier ones) are quite suitable content wise for children. Even if the child's literacy level is not up to scratch, the earlier books are child friendly enough that a parent/older reader can read it to them. Twilight's audience however needs to be quite a bit older. The content and focus of Twilight makes it an unsuitable book for children as it deals with teenage angst, sexual attraction, graphic violence, etc. It's not exactly a book a parent should read to their child at bedtime.

Also as a mostly pantasiya adventure book, Harry Potter is madami likely to appeal to both male and female audiences whereas the paranormal romance genre has traditionally been enjoyed sa pamamagitan ng a mostly female audience.

Harry Potter can be enjoyed sa pamamagitan ng children as young as 6-7 through to adults even though it's classified as a young adult's book. Twilight should only be read sa pamamagitan ng young adults (14-21) though to adults.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Thank you for your help.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
cleo7494 said:
First of all, I don't think that these two books should be compared. They are two different things. I've read all hp and twilight books and I've seen all the pelikula too. I like both and I'm not one of those who will argue about them.
In my opinion, HP is regarded as better, as it transfers the reader to a magic world, which is madami "innocent". Hogwards is portayed as a beautiful place, free from new thechnologies, mobiles or pcs. (for example we see that Hermione goes to the library). In twilight, the school is a typical modern one, where everyone go with their car. Also, the hp characters are perfect role models. The most important values for them are family, friendship, love. Whereas, in twilight there's only edward and the clumsy bella... Furthermore, Hp is sth different from what we know with the pag-ibig triangles and stuff.. It is very romantic and shows us that a girl and a boy can be actual mga kaibigan (Harry and Hermione, Harry isn't jealous of romione). Contrary to this, in twilight every boy goes after bella and they fight with eachother for her.

Finally, I like both twilight and hp, but i think nothing compares to the atmosphere of hp. Twilight is a phase, which in my opinion after some years will pass. HP is a lifestyle and it's sth that i want my children to read... Sorry for my English I hope I gave you some ideas!

select as best answer
 First of all, I don't think that these two books should be compared. They are two different things. I've read all hp and twilight books and I've seen all the pelikula too. I like both and I'm not one of those who will argue about them. In my opinion, HP is regarded as better, as it transfers the reader to a magic world, which is madami "innocent". Hogwards is portayed as a beautiful place, free from new thechnologies, mobiles or pcs. (for example we see that Hermione goes to the library). In twilight, the school is a typical modern one, where everyone go with their car. Also, the hp characters are perfect role models. The most important values for them are family, friendship, love. Whereas, in twilight there's only edward and the clumsy bella... Furthermore, Hp is sth different from what we know with the pag-ibig triangles and stuff.. It is very romantic and shows us that a girl and a boy can be actual mga kaibigan (Harry and Hermione, Harry isn't jealous of romione). Contrary to this, in twilight every boy goes after bella and they fight with eachother for her. Finally, I like both twilight and hp, but i think nothing compares to the atmosphere of hp. Twilight is a phase, which in my opinion after some years will pass. HP is a lifestyle and it's sth that i want my children to read... Sorry for my English I hope I gave you some ideas!
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Thank you very much.
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
;) i hope it will help you ;D
cleo7494 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
pag-ibig the pic, so true:)
graystone posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
haha! it is! :P
cleo7494 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
zanhar1 said:
Well since everyone else already sinabi the important stuff, I will just emphasize that HP has Bellatrix. And Bellatrix makes any book she's in better. :D
select as best answer
 Well since everyone else already sinabi the important stuff, I will just emphasize that HP has Bellatrix. And Bellatrix makes any book she's in better. :D
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Lol! I'll make sure I add that. Bellatrix's brilliant!
Helena-B-Carter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
SlythrnPrncss94 said:
steven king sinabi "Harry Potter is all about confronting fears, finding inner strength, and doing what is right in the face of adversity. Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend."
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
i agree!
sy-sy posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
TaylorASwift99 said:
Reasons why Harry Potter is better than twilight.
1. Harry potter actually tells a story while Twilight talks only of a relationship.
2. Many twilight fans are teenagers that don't know what they're doing while Harry Potter fans are much madami mature.
3. (this isn't really a reason but...) For the twilight fans, a few years from now, when you look back to the time you loved twilight, you will see how we (harry potter fans) feel right now.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
sy-sy said:
Well HP is better because first off the thing that sticks out the most to me is sacrifice. Jk was afraid to sacrifice characters for the good of the book. If you'll notice alot of important characters die in there. But in twilight almost no one important dies. Secondly, imagination. Everything Jk came up with was imaginative. Twilight was just predicitable. And HP's storyline to me is better. They were all best mga kaibigan brought to gether under certain circumstances. And you see the pag-ibig slowly devolp. In twilight i feel like all of it was rushed. But in HP they meet as kids and form a strong friendship before they start to really notice each other. And lastly the drama. In twilight it seems all of the drama can be directly traced back to bella. But in HP so many different people throw something else in the plot that it seems it's coming from every direction.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
alexisn10 said:
1. Harry Potter has a stronger female lead than Twilight does (Hermione vs. Bella or Ginny vs. Bella).
2. Harry Potter appeals to a much larger audience than Twilight.
3. The Harry Potter books and films usually get better critical acclaim than the ones of Twilight.
4. The Harry Potter films receive madami prestigious awards than the ones of Twilight.
5. JK Rowling has earned honorary degrees from Ivy League schools (and other very prestigious awards from Harry Potter) whereas Stepehenie Meyer hasn't.
6. The Potter series has a much better reputation than the Twilight series.
7. HP is the most successful film franchise (almost 8 billion dollars) of all time. Twilight is in 9th place (1 billion will probably hit 2 depending on how well BDP2 does).
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
next question »