Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Article: For People who think the Cullens could beat the Harry Potter Trio in a Battle...

31

For People who think the Cullens could beat the Harry Potter Trio in a Battle...

posted by XDRoseLuvsHP

I know a lot of people think the Cullen family could beat Harry, Ron and Hermione in a battle. I have read both series, and I realize that the Cullens have super speed and super strength. However, I do not think that the Cullens would stand a chance against the Trio.

Let's look back at the battle history of each...

The Cullens:
- They defeated James in the first book. However, there was only one of him and there were five of them, I believe? So that really isn't saying much.

- They defeated a band of immature Bampira with no fighting skills in Eclipse. They went in knowing they would win because of the fact the vamps they were fighting had no skills whatsoever in fighting. Again, not a big deal.

- At the end of Breaking Dawn, they were finally going to battle someone that would be somewhat of a challenge to them. So, what happens? They gather an army, and they talk. That's it. They let the supposedly evil Bampira just walk away and continue to be unjust. Um, does this strike anybody else as cowardly?

The Trio:
- Robbed Gringotts Wizarding Bank, which has never been done before, and all past wizards who have attempted have failed. I'd say that in itself is pretty impressive. But wait! There's more!

- Saved the Sorcerer's (Philosopher's) Stone from the clutches of Quirrel and, ultimately, Voldemort. You know how old they were when they did this? Eleven! How many eleven taon olds do you know who could do anything like that?

- Saved Ginny and the rest of the school from the horrors within the Chamber of Secrets (the Basilisk and Voldemort)

- Helped Sirius escape the clutches of the Ministry and defied hundreds of dementors. Only very skilled wizards can even produce a Patronus! Harry, at the age of 13, defied hundreds of them!

- Survived (and won) the Triwizard Tournament against witches and wizards older and madami advanced than Harry. This includes stealing an egg from a dragon, saving Ron from the merpeople and surviving the maze of doom (that is what I call it.)

- Faced of Voldemort unexpectedly and survived to tell the tale. At age 14.

- With mga kaibigan (Neville, Ginny, Luna), escaped the clutches of the Death Eaters at the Department of Mysteries (MUCH madami exciting in the book than the movie, just so you know)

- Collected and destroyed Voldemort's horcruxes

- Escaped with their lives from the Death Eaters on various occasions

- Final Battle: gathered an army and actually fought the Death Eaters. They suffered from loss, sacrifice and pain, but they did not give up and they did not give in. It was quite an intense battle, but in the end, Molly Weasley defeated Bellatrix single handedly, Neville killed off Nagini to make it possible to defeat Voldemort, and Harry went and defeated him single handedly as well.

- Many, many madami things as well. If I listahan them, it will take forever. If you want to find out more, read the books.

So, looking at their accomplishments, do you really think the Cullens would have the slightest chance against the Trio? I think not.

simpleplan, cookie324 and 29 others like this

11 more comments

loading additional comments...

Athiya Hem hem! Impedimenta! *insert slowed down vampires here* Petrificus Totalus! *insert frozen vampires here* Crucio! -- just for the fun of it *insert screeching vampires in agony here* Expulsio! -- because there would be additional fireworks :D *insert blown up vampires here*

Aquilia At Laura Cullen 66 and in some parts Athyia: A Freezing charm would descend everything around you into slowmotion (say 1-10% of your original speed) which means despite the Vampires incredible Superman-speed, under Immobulus they'll be doing 0.5-5 meters per second - walking-bicycling speed - very much an easy hit.

ABDCFan- Nice article! The Trio Wins. No Contest.

ravenclawgirl5 LEVICORPUS! The vamps can't super-speed run away when they're dangling in the air, can they? Great article!

ilovereading Alice: I see, the FUTURE. I can predict what they are going to do and... shit, we are going to lose.

sleazy_weasley Okay, Alice may be able to read the future, but really, in such an intense battle, she's not going to know every move the wizards pull at the core of the time. :) Sometimes the spells can be very instantaneous (uh, bad spelling), and Alice can only see foretold events; she thought Bella died, right? (Uh, whatever, werewolf). :( Okay, let's see how this would work ... The trio, Dumbledore's Army (Neville, Luna, Ginny), and Dumbledore himself vs. the Cullens; that's seven against *counts* (Ed, Bella, Al, Rosalie, Em, Jas, Carlz, Esme and Jacob) ... hm, bit unfair. Let's add Lupin to the list. Lupin vs. Jake: Lupin turns into full wolf, so does Jake. Jake still has his own mind, though. He is vulnerable. Lupin would eat him for an appetizer. ;) Harry/Dumbledore vs. Eddy/Carls: Occlumency, Fiendfyre, Dumbledore's voodoo. Hermes vs. Bella: Need I say more? It's like ... just, no. Ron vs. Emmet/Jasper: Okay, so Ron's not the best fighter, but let's get Ginevra to help. That's those two vamps down. Luna vs. Alice: Luna's so crazy Alice will simply get confuzzled. (Great argument I raise, I know). Death Eaters vs. Volturi: Dude. Like, Siriusly.

HecateA Only problem with Volturi vs deatheater, is that Jane and Alec are there, and I'm not sure that can be defied (thought it depends on who's quicker). Nice comment ilovereading. LOL. I follow Harry Potter, but sectemsempra wouldn't do anything, they have no blood (but in Half-blood prince (book) the inferi, also dead, get ripped apart.)

harrypotterbest you 4got he unexpectedly defeated and delayed Voldy on a almost broken leg!

luv_warriorcatz twilightfans keep on sayin that with a break of the "sticks", they're hoPELEs "this is a lie!" they can do magic without wands, they can make the luck potion and they can possibly learn how to call an animal from care of magical creatures

Angel-Trix luv_warriorcatz is right A niffler will come in handy

FredWRules and they can also just surround them with fiendfyre, then sit back and watch them burn.

hrrypttrfn328 I just thought of something that is a bit off-topic, but still a good thing to keep in mind in a case like this: I call your attention to any war in which the side with severe disadvantages came out victorious. Take the American Revolution for instance. Who would have thought the British would loose? It really does not only matter how powerful one side is, for the Cullens are technically more powerful, but ingenuity, determination, and a myriad of other things come into the mix to turn the tides. The characters in Harry Potter, as more fleshed out and human, have that determination and resourcefulness to come out ahead.

toradora1017 The trio could use Fiendfyre on the Cullens! :D They can also use the Forbidden Curses! Even if the Cullens have great speed and strength, they can be defeated with Patrificus Totalus! :D

Bellatrix-Black Luck potion's a good idea. Take a bit beforehand and it doesn't matter who's stronger, HP would win! And really, if it was all the characters from HP versus ass the characters from Twilight, as in, EVERY SINGLE ONE, HP has the advantage of numbers too! And the Deatheaters. Seriously.

ReibyKathBlack The Golden Trio will win ... ! no contest

Ultimately57 The answers easy-luck potion to secure your survival and incendio all around around you, and they can just take off on their brooms. For comedy effect, fly high on brooms, and drop dungbombs. They breath out of habit, and they have super smelling powers. This result is hilarious.

RandomRebekah Harry Potter would WIN.

lovemarauders For the Volturi vs. Death Eaters: Theres a sheild charm right? (I think there is, I'm not sure.) The Death Eaters can use that against Jane and Alecs powers :)

ladywyze Ha! Load of CRAPS! The Cullens just have to steal their WANDS and it would be finish! They(the Cullens) got SPEED, STRENGTH and INTELLIGENCE! They even had ALICE and EDWARD! Your GOLDEN TRIO, even of they're wizards, their humans, right? About the Article: Oh yes, they gathered ARMIES to fight the VOLTURI. But. BUT remember they only(intentionally) just asked them to witness. Not to FIGHT, all right? Oh yes(again), they fought UNSKILLED vampires with TREMENDOUS strength far greater than theirs. And they do it to prevent Human lives to lose. (Okay?) Oh yes(once more), they defeated James. JAMES THE TRACKER, respectively. You know a TRACKER? Maybe not because you HATE Twilight. THE CULLENS WOULD WIN, NO DOUBT. And. And REMEMBER, endless questioners, that TWILIGHT is FICTION. You shouldn't judge it just because, why do their vampires sparkle? Why do, what, where, when, how... it's just a FICTION, for crying out loud! You sure love VERSUS

LavenderBrown HP wins. No doubt. First, they impediment those sparklepires. They slow down, what good is super speed now? Then, Petrificus Totalus. They stop completely, easy hit. Now a bit of Fiend Fyre. (Fire you can't put out.) Surrond the Vamps with it. Now fly up on brooms to above the Fyre. Send jinxes, hexes and curses from above. HP wins.

rbweasley How would a vampire be able to land a hit, with the Shield charm? No matter how hard the vamps try, they can get past an impenetrable physical barrier. And the Occlumency is basically like a mental shield, so not mental attacks, and no way for Edward, or any other mental vampires (Jane, Alec, Zafrina- and you tell us that we don't read Twilight) would be able to get them. So now that the sparkly vamps can't hit them, they just use Fiendfyre, or Incendio, or whatever. Mayber they could even get some of the fireworks from the Weasleys and just blow them up that way :)

HPfan236 vampires can be killed with fire and Harry potter does have a fire spell so Trio would kick there ass

LottieVal99 Yeah, nifflers love shiny stuff and they should also send a few magpies to attack the sparkly losers. Otherwise @ladywyze , Yes Alice can read the future but it's limited (As stated by stephanie meyer but she does tend to contradict herself a LOT). Edward wouldn't be able to read thier minds as they would practice Occlumency. Though the vampires may be able to 'sparkle' in the sun, the glitters not really going to help them a lot is it? Fiendfyre can't be put out by any other person than the person who lit it and glitter has no effect whatsoever on it.

FishermansWife Many people forget: Hermione could turn any of the Cullens into an ant and squash them, or a banana and eat them, etc

Minervina ^^yeahh!!!! Great artical

6

So the Twilight tagahanga came up and said.......

posted by KateKicksAss

I found this online. It's a real conversation a bookstore employee apparently had with a Twilight fan. It didn't happen to me. I found it funny, thought you guys might too.

(A customer in her late teens approaches me in the bookstore.)
Customer: “Hey, do you guys sell the Twilight books?”
Me: “Yes, they’re right over there.”
Customer: “Have you read them?”
Me: “Yes, I have.”
Customer: “Didn’t you just pag-ibig them?!”
Me: “Well, actually, they aren’t really my type of book, so–”
Customer: *suddenly furious* “Are you f***ing serious?! These are the best books ever written! I’m going to tell Edward to come and bite you and drink all your blood!”
Me: *backing away* “Have a nice day, ma’am…”

Muggles vs. Non-vampires

posted by ilovereading

I was thinking about difference in Harry Potter and Twilight background and this is what I concluded. Enjoy!

Knowledge of magical beings not soo very far from their backyards
Harry Potter: As I can get from HP books and The Tales of Beedle the Bard, wizarding world was known to Muggles, but because of witch hunt and victims of it in both sides, wizard decided to go underground and not to be commonly know to people. They don`t use spells in front of Muggles and if sombody does manage to discover their secret, they erase their memory.
However, there are exeptions. Families of Mugle-borns ofcourse...

harry meets edward

posted by june13

were are you harry asked ron over here can't you see me am right in front of you.
no i cant see you it's so drak a cat even could not see in here.

hah ron very funny, lets try to find a light swicht for you can see.
ron i found one. well then turn it one then
i am don't worry

boo am going to suck your owls blood.
right then the sun came toungt the window and then edward begin to spark

look harry this vamiper sparks how sad is that.

ron is he waring girls cothing
yay i think he is

no am not but am in pag-ibig with a human girl

harry and ron at the same time laghed them selfed silly

and that's the end of this fine story

5

A Rant About Twilight And Harry Potter.

posted by Guste_LT

THIS IS JUST MY PERSONALL OPINION, FEEL FREE TO DISAGREE, THIS IS JUST WHAT I THINK, NOT THE ENTIRE POPULATION OF TWILIGHT FANS. SO PLEASE UNDERSTAND THIS IS MY PERSONAL OPINION!!!!!!

Thank you.

Just so you know, this is a Twilight tagahanga speaking.

Twilight may NOT be the best book ever, i didnt say that it was (keep that in mind), when i read it, i saw alot of flaws, like in breaking dawn, Meyer made it clear that vamps cant inject sperm, and yet, somehow Bella got pregnant. I've read this artikulo sa pamamagitan ng XDRoseLuvsHP, and i totaly agree. I believe that People like Twilight madami thatn HP because it...

Emma & Taylor

added by youknowit101

Source: crackandship@tumblr

:) x

added by Italktosnakes

Source: Whatthefawkes.tumblr.com

1

harry potter

posted by bakura1234

It has a PLOT! It has Subplots.It has several characters with depth.JK is not afraid to sacrifice the good guys. The characters aren't one dementional. JK researches her material, has good use of Latin and history within her books. Spells are named after Latin words and do what the Latin words do. Names of soem characters give hints as to what that character is such as Sirius which means Dog bituin for madami Albus which means White (pure wizard). You can relate Harry Potter to WWII because of similarities you could learn some history from the books.
Harry Potter teaches a good deal about prejudice...

6

The Internet and Maturity

posted by Kersian

Okay this is madami of an opinion, since my view of the activity is based off opinion.

Now whenever someone posts something on the internet and someone else responds negatively to it, they respond in the same way to that person. In a very negative tone. This is in fact what I see at times in forums.

First Twilight and Harry Potter fans, if you post anything on the internet, whether they are opinions or facts, you have responsibilities with it. You are exposing yourself to others in the internet. You are responsible for the positive or negative replies. So don't blame others for your actions....