Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Club
sumali
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
I'm tired of repeating myself and other HP fans repeating themselves constantly so here is my opinion on why Harry Potter is better. So you don't think I'm being biased, let me tell you: I read Harry Potter when I was 5 and have been a tagahanga since (and that shuts down the comment that little kids can't read it sa pamamagitan ng the way) and when I was 13, I read Twilight (before the bandwagon) and loved it. Then just recently, I got off the Twilight High. So I know how it is to have liked Twilight and to like Harry Potter.

First, we can look at the authors. JK Rowling is the epitome of Rag to Riches. She started out in poverty, got a brilliant idea and wrote it on napkins and had a daughter to support. She was rejected multiple times and worked 17 years on the background of characters, places, and names. She did that so well, you can picture it perfectly and make a whole series off of another character! Finally with a lot of hard work made it to her status and one of the highest paid women of today's time.

Meyer, on the other hand, had a dream and wrote it down. She spent 3 months on it and it barely got rejected before it became a hit with girls everywhere. Now she has money. It shows. It really shows who put madami time into it.

Now, on the moral of the stories. Harry Potter. Wow, I can write a book on everything someone can learn off of that! First it teaches about Friendship. I think that is the one thing I wish I had was mga kaibigan like the trio. It teaches you how real mga kaibigan are always there and should be loyal. It teaches you about life and how important it is. How one person can make a change in others. And death. How important death is. How heartbreaking and how to deal with it. After all "To the well organized mind, death is but the susunod great adventure." It shows how important choice is, and how fate and destiny can be changed sa pamamagitan ng one action. If only Voldemort didn't view Harry as the threat, Harry's future could have been changed and Neville would be in his place. Your future isn't always up to you, but you have the choice to change it for the better. Harry grew up in the same environment as Tom Riddle, yet Harry chose to pag-ibig instead of hate. And the act to forgive. Harry forgave Pettigrew for being a traitor, Voldemort for not loving and killing everyone, and others. Do you know how much strength that takes to forgive your enemies who are the reason why you grew up miserably? It shows what that simple act can be so strong. And prejudice. Remus is the prime example. He's a werewolf and accomplished so much. He had a family, a job, a life, and friends. It's telling people to get over it. People are different. It doesn't mean they're bad!

And most of all. Love. It's not "I need a boyfriend" love. No. It's the type of pag-ibig that saves a life. Lily gave up her own life to save her son when she knew the chances of him surviving were slim. James gave up his life to give his wife and son a chance. PLUS Lily had a choice to ilipat aside and she didn't. That's pag-ibig in it's rawest form. There is pag-ibig of sibling like figures (The Trio), and pag-ibig for parent-like figures (Sirius, Remus, and the Weasleys). pag-ibig is even looked down upon (Remus and Tonks) but it was strong and prevailed even into death. And there is unrequited pag-ibig (Cho Chang and Harry). Stalker pag-ibig (Romilda Vaine and Lavender Brown.) And boyfriend/girlfriend type pag-ibig that is madami natural (Harry/Ginny, Hermione/Ron).

In Twilight there is unrequited pag-ibig and "soul mate" forms. But it's not natural (at all) and it's mainly boyfriend girlfriend type. There is no parental pag-ibig really shown. Especially not in the sisne family. The Cullens, yes you could say that, but not really. They never really ipakita the acts of love.

Another thing Harry Potter improved upon in the "showing" area is good and evil. They ipakita you how the boundries form. Why the characters become good or why they become evil. How people can change sides. Examples: Dumbledore became good because of guilt of what happened to his sister. Voldemort became evil because he grew up in the orphanage and without love. And he hated his father and being only a half-blood. Pettigrew went to Voldemort's side because he feared for his life. His fear beat his loyalty thus killing James and Lily. Harry Potter blended the line of Good and Evil.

In Twilight, you don't get an insight as to why James is the way he is. You don't get to see why Carlisle had the control not to eat humans. The REAL reason as to why he chose to go after deer. Or why others stayed with them. You don't see why people went to the side they did. And if you do, it's a really shallow reason. Why did James, Victoria, and Laurant (aka Black Eyed Peas. haha) get together?

Now, let's look at plot. Harry Potter brought on a whole new concept. A simple boy who becomes a chosen one because of an mahirap paniwalaan accident. The plot had so many hidden plots beneath it like the Hallows that was there the whole time (Invisibility Cloak, Gaunt's Ring, and Elder Wand were all in the books before they had significance). And mini plots. Plus each book had a new essence to it. New enemies brought up, new friends, new information, and new areas in the magical world were viewed. YOU GAINED KNOWLEDGE WITH THE TRIO!

In Twilight, you gain that Edward is a vampire from the back of the book. It takes out a lot of the suspense. And the plot is basically how Edward and Bella will get together. It wasn't until Breaking Dawn where Meyer tried to throw in a real plot and ruined it terribly.

Now for the realistic appeal. Harry, Ron, and Hermione weren't mga kaibigan right off the bat. Harry and Ron were. But they made fun of Hermione and hated her. It wasn't til the middle of the first book that they befriended her. Even then Ron and Hermione had love/hate friendship going on. And their relationships don't start off like a snap of the finger. It starts as awkward or with hate and then progresses to a crush and love. It took Ron and Hermione 7 years (Harry and Ginny too). And they had others they saw too. Harry had Cho. Ginny had Dean. Ron had Lavender. Hermione had Viktor. Not only that, but with social classes too. The Weasley's are poor, The Dursley's the average family, The Malfoy's are the wealthy. It even has status quo's like Sirius being a criminal. And Remus is a pariah!

And War. It's not just one person or one side that dies. Rowling had everyone going that Harry was going to DIE after the Prophecy was made. Especially when he walked to his death as a sacrifice (another moral and another sign of love). He did live, but look at who died:
Good: Tonks, Remus, Hedwig, Mad-Eye, Sirius, Dumbledore, Snape, Creevy, Fred, George's Ear (there are injuries in war too!), The Longbottoms, The Potters, The Original Order.
Bad: Voldemort, Pettigrew, Snape, Death Eaters, etc.
This makes it realistic. And yes, Hedwig counts. The characters were written so well people CRIED when Hedwig died (I know I did).

Stephenie has Edward and Bella be their first couple and it's right off the bat that they like each other practically. You see the same social classes... everywhere in forks. Yes even in small towns, there are social classes. And most of all WAR. Or lack there of. Irena dies. That's it. She was leading to a war and backed out too afraid to offend anyone. And if characters died, they weren't written well enough that a lot would cry over them. Pity yes, but not cry. (If a Cullen died. I'd feel bad for their mate).

Feminism. I'm all about the whole "Girls can do whatever guys can do" stuff. Believe me. And Bella sisne does not cut it. She relies on the men in her life and spends her time at tahanan cooking and cleaning. Meyer claims Bella is smart and reads a lot but doesn't ipakita it. Bella reads about 1 book the entire time and it's stated once she was in advanced classes. That's not enough.

Instead, look at Hermione, Luna, Ginny, and Tonks.

Hermione: Her strong points are her flaws. She's intelligent. She read Hogwarts: A History before even going to school as a Muggle-born. She also knew spells ont he train when going to her first year. She's loyal and caring. She stuck with Harry in DH even when Ron left because of her Promise. And helped with Neville finding his toad. Yes, she can be bossy with her confidence, but she does have confidence and she is an outcast.

Luna: Marches to her own beat. She doesn't care what others think. She says what she thinks.

Ginny: Isn't mentioned as much, but she sticks up to Harry when he is a git and doesn't go all zombie when he leaves. She starts rebellions at Hogwarts and even goes as far as trying to get Godric Gryffindor's Sword.

Tonks: A female Auror. She backtalks to Moody when no one does that. She has guts and humor and is the sore thumb because she's a Metamorphmagus and uses it to her advantage. The first scene with her shows how positive and how in charge her presence is when she snaps at Moody's behavior and also makes a 'butt' joke.

Even the quotes. Harry Potter mga panipi have so much madami meaning. I could make another artikulo for those! One of my meaningful mga panipi happens to be from Dumbledore: "Time is making fools of us again." I pag-ibig that.

Twilight had "And so the Lion fell in pag-ibig with the Lamb." It's rather shallow compared to anything Dumbledore has ever said.

And look at the thinking aspect. Harry Potter had to questioning and forming theories the whole time: Who is RLB? What side is Snape?! What would have happened if Harry died in the end? What would the world have been like? I wonder why Kreacher had that necklace? What happened to Fluffy? What's the veil really about? How did Lily and James get together? What about the Marauder era?etc. It's a thought provoker.

Twilight asks you what side Bella should choose.

And the audience. Harry Potter reaches out to all ages and genders. Twilight reaches out to preteens and girls.

OK... there were other points I had but forgot while going off about the War aspect. But hopefully you all catch my drift. If you have any comments, additions, or want to pagtatalo please comment or even to give your opinion.

Oh and if that doesn't convince you. One word will ipakita how epic Potter is:

Quidditch.
added by youknowit101
Source: iheartrobandkristen@tumblr
added by youknowit101
Source: cafepress
added by youknowit101
Source: psychadeliachild@tumblr
added by Italktosnakes
Source: tumblr
added by Italktosnakes
Source: tumblr
added by goodtimes
added by bddh
Source: tumblr
added by Italktosnakes
Source: Whatthefawkes.tumblr.com
Both twilight and harry potter are very successful, especially among teenagers. Some people keep arguing about which is better, though in my opinion, THEY SHOULDN'T BE COMPARED!

Now, i have to admit i pag-ibig both series! I'd say harry potter is unisex and appropriate for all ages, whilst twilight adresses mainly to teenage girls. HP talks about friendship and love, while twilight is madami romantic! Also, hp gives lessons of life, although maybe in some cases, i would prefer pagbaba twilight.

Finally, They are both written sa pamamagitan ng two very talented and imaginative writers, j.k rowling and stephenie meyer. They wrote these books to give teens (and not only) inspiration and time of happiness. So, if you don't like one of these two series, don't blame them! We can't all have the same tastes!
First part
link

She gestured to a row of wooden
chairs against the wall. The looked like they belonged with someone’s dinning room
table.
“Okay,” I agreed. I walked over to the chairs and sat right in the middle,
suddenly wishing I had a book. I hadn’t read anything for a while, outside of school.
And even then, when some ridiculous pag-ibig story was part of the curriculum, I would
cheat with cliff notes. It was a relief to be working on Animal Farm now. But there had
to be other ligtas books. Political thrillers. Murder mysteries. Grisly murders were no
problem; just as long as there was no starry-eyed,...
continue reading...
posted by victorodonnell
The World is flat!
    Well, I know you tanong my sanity, now. Obviously, the world is round and that’s a proven fact, from the moment Galileo stepped out of his ship. And now, there’s a tanong again. Is the World really round? I hate that word, really. The word which gives rise to a lot of tanong and seeks for explanations.
    ‘Imagination is madami important than knowledge,’ sinabi a wise man once. And, it’s true. Well, you need not be aware of the complications of four-dimensional puwang fabric to accept this theory. What all you need to...
continue reading...
posted by siriuslyawesome
tanong fans and sagot from walang tiyak na layunin people



Who is better: Harry or Edward? Why?

A: I think Harry is better. He has flaws in his character that make him relatable. He puts himself in danger and sacrifices himself for his friends. He may be a wizard, but he feels what normal kids feel: anger, betrayal, sadness, loss, joy, relief, confidence, and bravery.
-anonymous HP fan
A2-Edward. Edward would die for Bella, and tries to protect her in any way he can. He doesn't give up on her even when he hears she is with Jacob and saves her innumerable times.
Anonymous T fan.


Quidditch or Vampire Baseball?...
continue reading...
posted by ImBooOK
Before you read this, i must tell you something a little important. You may dilike my opinions, and i can deal with it. But this is just what i think, and why i choose both books.

Lets get down to the movie versus books.
Im talking books here people, not the movie stars who play them, not witch guy is hotter, who has madami abs. NOT talking about that. Im speaking about how good both Twilight and Harry Potter (or other way around because i have seen fans fight about who i type in first...witch in truth is really childish) is.
Harry Potter. Its a very detailed and continuous story. I like how the...
continue reading...
posted by sapherequeen
Hi, everyone :)

I first want to apologize for my leaving, and never telling anyone that I decided to go, why I wanted to go, any good-bye's etc. It's been something that has bothered me for a little while, and I truly apologize for that.

A friend of mine told me that someone asked about me on here, so I thought that I could write an artikulo explaining why I left and why I decided to come back.

You see, around the time I stopped coming here, I was having problems with my life outside Fanpop. I don't want to talk about it, but I will say that it had a lot to do with friends, family, and school and...
continue reading...
PART FOUR:

Okay. Okay. I am a perfectly calm boy yes. That’s it. I will make myself forget what has just happened. There. All good. I forgot. (OH HERE LET ME HELP: HARRY, YOU JUST SET A SNAKE ON THAT JUSTIN FLICKEY KID AND NOW THE ENTIRE SCHOOL THINKS YOURE THE AIR OF SLYTHERIN!!!! ) Oh yeah. Thank you Emily. (YOURE WELCOME ) anyways because Emily is so eager to talk I should just let her share her point of view on things. Oh and Emily, its spelled h-e-i-r not a-i-r. A-i-r is what your head is full of. ( FINE, AND BTW YOU OWE ME A GALLION FOR THAT SMILEY. ANYWAYS, PEACE IS pagganap FUNNY, SHES...
continue reading...
Once there was a young teenage girl named Hadley. She was walking around at the local aklatan looking for some new books to read. While she was there, Hadley stumbled upon something. It was a black hardback book with two hands holding an mansanas with the word, "Twilight" on it. This interested Hadley and she decided to buy it. When she did, she got hooked. Hadley bought the other three books and after she read them, became a Twitard. She even started to think that Harry Potter and all the other pantasiya books she liked weren't as good as Twilight. She drew pictures of the characters, wrote fangirl...
continue reading...
Alright, part II is here! It's still pretty bad writing, but it gets better.

Dear Peace's Diary,
Peace blacked out. I don't know why. She just did. She’s just laying down in the middle of the common room she looks kind of dead.
Me Crabbe and goyle are taking her to Madam Pomfrey.
~Draco Malfoy





I visited peace in the hospital wing. She still isn’t awake yet. Carsilile sinabi she will be alright in a couple of days. But carsilile seemed a little nervous. Edward sinabi it was just because I was giving him the "don’t you dare lay a tooth on my best friend" look. I dint know what happened, but I...
continue reading...
posted by bamagirl5899
okay dont leave bad comments if u dont like this ok i am having a bad day.

May pov

I was almost out the door when Alice said,"Do you want to go hunting?" I turned around to look at my best friend who knows how long it was nakaraan when she saved me from dying in that carwreck it still brought back bad memories and also good ones that was the araw I became a vamp. "Sure Alice. Does anyone ealse want to come?" I said. A little girl well a girl younger than me ran up and sinabi "I do please take me, oh and I'm rennesme."she said. then Bella ran up and grabed her arm and she sinabi "No u cannot go with her."...
continue reading...
Let's set the scene before this begins shall we? A girl, we'll call her Ven, is walking tahanan from school and gets a call from her friend. Ven and sinabi friend have not spoken in a while so they start to ask what the other has been up to. They eventually get into the subject of books they've read. And that's where this little story starts.


So Ven's friend asks her what her favortie book is. "Oh, that's an easy one." she replies. "Harry Potter of course." her friend laughs and says, "Of course. Well, my paborito book series is Twilight."


Ven, having never even heard of the books, makes a confused...
continue reading...
posted by HaleyDewit
Well,here's my first attempt to a short story :)

“Hey! Stop him! He’s stealing!!!!” the owner shouted. Ron ran as fast as he could, but he didn’t get far. Only a few yards from the tindahan he collapsed to a large person and fell on the ground. The ring fell susunod to him and the man understood what was going on. He picked Ron and the ring off the floor and dragged him back to the jewelry shop. “I think this boy has something that’s yours” the man sinabi looking at the tindahan owner and he gave back the ring. “Thanks” the owner accepted in relief.
“What’s going on?” a familiar...
continue reading...