A Small Collection Of Negative Harry Potter Reviews 

In response to the feminist review: not as bad as Twilight.

John Mark Eberhart (the Age, June 2003)
"The plot is cumbersome. Most characters haven't bloomed; they've only aged. Settings are befogged by vague writing."

Has this guy even read the book? The plot is amazing he hasn't got a clue!

""The values that triumph in the Harry Potter books are those of a nostalgic, conservative Little Britain"

So . . . good conquering evil, love conquering all,friendship through adversity are "nostolgic, conservative Bristish" values? My bad. I thought those were values everyone should have . . .

I love how they all oppose each other: one review says there isn't any social commentary at all, and another says most of it is about the "British class prejudice social commentary." One review says the characters are flat and unchanging, and one says that's one of the very few strong points in the book XD

^ I know right

I've seen all these before. The critisisms are very baseless.

It's funny how a lot of these reviews were written before all the books were out. I'd like to see what some of them have to say now that they have the entire story.

I'd like to see them review Twilight.

I don't listen to other people's critism...I get my own opinion

as asn author, one has to accept bad as well as good reviews.