Brendan, Kenny, and Mike try to get out of their dating slump sa pamamagitan ng going to a pick-up bar, but are foiled sa pamamagitan ng PJ joining them. Stephanie tries to get PJ to be madami feminine. Brendan gets back together with Wendy.
PJ takes part in a local cable sports ipakita and shows a poor performance. The boys try to hide it from her, but in the end are forced to tell her she "swung and missed
PJ confesses that she and Brendan made out in college. PJ gets annoyed when Brendan claims to have forgotten that he 'wassup-ed' her after their kiss, as no one remembers the incident.
PJ tries to understand "the kiss" she shared with Brendan and why he's pagganap so oddly toward her. Meanwhile the gang is surprised when they meet Kenny's new girlfriend, Kimmie, who happens to be pregnant.
The boys find out about PJ and Bobby previously dating. PJ tries to setup Mike's friend with Stephanie, which backfires, as Mike's friend is attracted to PJ instead.
PJ and Bobby get their signals mixed up about their relationship, due to PJ's exsessive use of baseball metaphors, so the guys don't find out about their nakaraan relationship. Bobby ends up dating a new girl, Claire.
