Who do you think made Brooke happier? (Other than the cheating and Alex) poll Results - One puno burol

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

One puno burol Who do you think made Brooke happier? (Other than the cheating and Alex)

85 fans picked:

Julian

73%

Lucas

27%

othluver posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas

Make your pick! | next poll >>

14 comments

	comet-love picked Julian: IMO Brooke was never really truly happy with Lucas! There was always one sort of problem... :/ posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	mcewen_girl picked Julian: I think Brooke was happy with Lucas, but not quite the way she is with Julian. Still gotta love my BL though. posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Julian: It seemed to me like Brooke had more unhappy times with Lucas, rather than happy ones yes, Lucas made her happy at times. But not in the same way that Julian does. I think she is more deeply, stabley (I know, not a word lol), and maturely happy with Julian. Where as I think her relationship with Lucas was more of a silly, young, high school relationship type of happy posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	carambolas picked Julian: I don´t think Brooke was ever really happy and at peace in her relationship with Lucas. I believe Julian can make her happier than Lucas ever could. posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	ns_23 picked Julian: ^ 100% agreed :) posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	simysimy picked Julian: agreed with all of you posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	Kirkir picked Julian: I agree with TheBoySawAComet..her relationship with Lucas was more of a silly highschool one. And I think there was always the problem with Peyton. With Julian..she's more settled <3 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	Team_Brooke picked Julian: ^Totally! posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	Lisiii picked Lucas: I know Brucas was just "a young (I think I'm gonna delete the word "silly" ^^) highschool relationship" but that doesn't mean she wasn't happy with him. I always thought, although she seemed a little insecure when she was with him, Brooke was incredibly...herself back then. You know...I never had the feeling she kinda dissembled, she was just Brooke(-ish). She was natural, bubbly, dominant and funny...and I think that got/gets kind of lost in season 6 and 7. It's probably the writing but I think she seems even more insecure right now...I think that feeling's never gonna disappear though. Besides, you wrote "other than the cheating and Alex"...maybe she wouldn't have been that insecure if Lucas hadn't had a "fling" (sort of) with Peyton in season 1?! Because she said it herself: "I was afraid of being vulnerable again. With you." That's maybe one of the "not so happy" parts but almost every "not so happy" part was about her being insecure. Okay, what I'm trying to say is (^^) I don't think you can really judge her happiness with Luke and Julian, just based on the former seasons whithout considering the "cheating and Alex" thing. Because maybe that'd mean a totally different Brooke... And yes, I believe Julian is totally going to make her happy as well (that's just who he is. He'd never wanna hurt Brooke by purpose, it just happens because of some really bad choices) but I still think she seemed a little happier in her highschool years...when she was with Lucas...or maybe even Felix, whatever xP Or it's just the writing that has changed for me / = posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	jemgrl323 picked Lucas: I love Brulian and while they have SOME happy moments... they are far and few between!! Almost every single episode in which they have been a couple- they have gotten into a fight and Brooke either ended up crying or yelling. In season 6 in every episode they were a couple they got into a fight, and now in season 7- there have only been 3 episodes in which they were a couple that they did not get into a fight or Brooke did not act depressed. I love Brooke, I love Julian, and I love Brooke & Julian as a couple... but I would never describe their relationship as a happy one. They spend much more time fighting and crying and than being happy. Lucas and Brooke have fought... but no OTH couple has fought as much as Brulian. We saw Brooke smile sooo much more when she was with Lucas. I'm not saying she loved Lucas more than Julian or even that she is better off with Lucas... but I am saying that despite any insecurities she may have had with Lucas, she definitely seemed happier with him than with Julian. I barely even remember Brooke's smile anymore--- it seems like all we ever get is tears! Hopefully these next 4 episodes will have many HAPPY Brulian scenes posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	AMYonetreehill picked Julian: To me Brucas were never a happy relationship, there was always omething that they were trying to overcome, like an obstical or a person standing in their way, they seemed to spend all their time fighting for their relationship so they couuld be happy -but never actally spent any time just being happy 'happy' -Brooke spent the etire time feeling second best, jelous & paranoid & like she was never good enough for him. -And Lucas spent the time hiding from his real feelings for his real true love. Julian though makes Brooke happy, they have so many scenes not drama filled or fighting for what they want or having to get through anything, and we just see them carefree,young and in love -just a couple who are genuinally happy in eachothers company, have you saw how big Brookes smile is when shes with Julian, i can honestly say ive never seen her happier than whenshes with him ♥ posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	Nibylandija picked Julian: she has less of drama with him,so. posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	Ginevraaa picked Julian: BRUCAS will always be my very very first favourite OTH couple but the truth is Lucas made her miserable. Julian made her smile and a lot happier than Lucas. posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.

	Bangel90 picked Julian: I'm a Brucas but I think Julian, overall, made her happier. Never cheated on her, married her, did everything for her so yeah, she's much happier now. posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas.