the way she cries .. it broke my heart .

Lindsey or Amanda! I like Scott, too. Hate Shantel...

Lindsey is awesome too! Her acting is always spot on! Just incredible!

Lindsey & Amanda..Definitely not Shantel lol

Lindsey's amazing.Amanda is great as well.Scott's good and well Shantel...hmmm...no comment....

Sry but Shantel's acting didn't really convince me / = I like Quinn though : D
Lindsey's just...WOW! She's so believable, spirited and full of emotions! She totally had me since the first OTH episode she was in ( =

I just love Lindsay as Taylor is just AWESOME! I would have love to see her as a regular in the show instead of Shantel!
Shantel is really beautiful but she isn't a good actress so I can't choose her!
Amanda was great as Sara, she's one of my fave character on Oth even if it was just for 1 eppy as an alive character and the others as a ghost! I just love how cute her couple with Clay was!
She did a great job as the psycho tennis girl (don't remember her name though)! She reminds me of Nanny Carrie lol!

ummm DUHHH. lmfao shantel?! seriously! LMFAO, thats gota be a joke. she cant act to save her life. the main reason i hate quinn is cuz of shantel's shitty portrayel of her character. yeaa lindsey forsure. umm just go rewatch the scene taylor had with lydia in the hospital. and then would be amanda, her portrayel of sara was so heartbraking, yet at the same time she switched to creepy stalker mode super well too, i genuinley felt like i was watching 2 different people.