If you had a chance to re-make the movie your way, would you do it?

a million times yes, i think the fans would do a better job directing it than professional directors. :)

I actually put up a script at one club.

And I'm pretty sure this counts as spam since its not a HoO movie.

without a doubt. although i think it was a good film just not as good (and too different) to the book

I so think that the fans would have done a better job!

YEEESS!!!!

sure

OH HELL TO THE YEAH!!!!

Definitely. It was a great movie, but they could have payed a lot closer attention to the book.

YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES!
the only thing that i would not replace would be Percy... i mean... the movie was nothing like the book, but Logan Lerman was like Percy

yes i would make it so you can at least add the sequels because the first movie was completely wrong you cant really make the sea of monsters after that one and none of the books after that plus what happens if the Nawawala hero ids a hit how are they going to make movie about that if you havent gotten to know the characters that well if you havent read the books(but i recommend you should)

Copy the book word for word. And make annath blond! Who cares if it would take four hours of bliss! The books were popular for a reason.

ABSOLUTELY!
i keep watching it over and over again, and i actually have a listahan of the things that i would like to change, one of them being the actors. but, another thing to look at is the events that happened. i mean, sure the entrance to the sa ilalim ng daigdig is in Hollywood, but its in DOA Studios, not in the big Hollywood sign! i am sorry, but i really get annoyed with stuff like this-when directors dont follow the story >:(

and honestly, the fans know the book better than the directors, so they would be better to direct it :S they should have made the director read the book 20+ times like i did :) THEN it would be a better movie.

Yes. Defiantly.

Definately! I should have directed it! I would have done it from the book and with actors the right age!

Of course I'd redo it. Although it wasn't bad, the movie just didn't bring justice to the books.

Yes, yes, yes, yes please!!! I would recast the cast and make the actors, oh I don't know, twelve?!!! And (I don't know why, but this was the main reason why I hated the movie compared to the book) the first thing percy would say when he woke up in infirmary would be "you drool when you sleep".

YES. And I'd do it right!

Um, HECKS YEA! That movie was an absolute disgrace to the book. The only reason I pag-ibig the movie is because it was based on a TOTALLY FRICKIN AWESOMELY AMAZING BOOK!!
But other than that, the movie sucked. And then making Percy 17 (?!?!?!) in the movie?! He's not even 17 in the books!!! That means the First Great Prophecy had already past, which makes no sense making a movie about a boy, leading up to an event that has already past! I loved but hated the movie, so I'm really conflicted.
But a THOUSAND TIMES YES (!!!!!!!) if I could remake the movie. And Annabeth's HAIR! I would bet my copy of the Lightning Thief that that was the topic that got the most hate mail!

I would. If I could re-make the movie, I wouldn't miss a detail. I would put in every scene from the book and not miss 1 line. Basically, it would be a 20 oras long movie. But I wouldn't mind because it would be perfect. P.S. I would cast the perfect people for the characters from the book.