Vitani look just like Kiara when they where cubs. She has Nala's bright blue eyes and Kiara's balahibo color but darker, so could have Nala mated with Scar or is it a genetic thing from Scars side of the family?
Umm..No! Nala only has one child and it's Kiara. Vitani is not close to Kiara as a relative. Vitani maybe Scar's or a walang tiyak na layunin lion that Zira mated with. When Kiara and Kovu are married then she becomes Kiara's sister in law.
Nep. Scar is Nala and Simba's uncle. durr. BTW, Their family puno is so complicated. Scar and Mufasa are brothers so that's why Scar became Simba and Nala's uncle. Scar has 3 children (1 is adopted, Kovu..or maybe....also Vitani so that will be 2). Kovu, Vitani and Nuka are suppose to be Nala and Simba's cousins but since they we're exiled and outlanders in that moment they never had that relationship (Just like two people didn't know each other). But they started all over again in the ending of Lion King 2, well.. DUH! I told you it's complicated. But people this is only MY OPINION, no big deal please ^^
wait..! What am I crazy? saying all of those family puno above?! They're lions! durr..., silly of me, I wasted my time. -_-
My answer is that they are half sisters. Vitani does have a balahibo tone similar to Kiara's but also Similar to Simba I say Vitani's father is Simba but her bright blue eyes suggest a genetic thing due to Scar being Simba's uncle. Her scar shaped nose came from her mother. As well as her other outsider features.I did sense some sexual tension between Simba and Zira meaning her and Nala ' s rift could not be only over Kopa but A secret mate ship between Simba and Zira in order to produce a cub fit for royalty because of Nuka being a disappointment. But Vitani ended up being a girl. So she had to come up with another plan.
No. Nala nor Simba are in any way related to any of Zira's cubs except through marriage. Nala wasn't Scar's mate. Scar doesn't have any known mates or cubs. There is a deleted scene where Scar tries to get Nala as his queen. But she refuses. Which is a clue that Nala × Scar wouldn't work. Simba isn't Vitani's dad either. Zira is her mother though. Vitani doesn't call Nala mom. She also doesn't call Simba or Scar dad. Vitani most likely gets her blue eyes from early story ideas or her father. Almost every simba's pride novelization including a Disney Book which I bought myself included Zira with blue eyes. The book i bought also included the deleted scene Another Cub. And the one with Kovu's original first appearance. There was also an idea where Zira had green eyes. In what looked like a sketch near production showed Zira holding Kovu with what appeared to be Esmeralda green eyes. Also I've heard that Zira's eyes were supposed to be green like Kovu's. Vitani's dad could also be where her kulay-rosas nose came from. And her lighter color. Scar nor simba is most likely not her dad for madami than one reason. I'll be happy to give you the short list.
Reasons why Scar is Not her dad. (1) In the deleted scene it says Scar chose Kovu To Be His successor as a dying wish. (2) In the song Not One Of Us the . The lyrics say born in grief . Raised in hate. We know where raised in hate comes from. But born in grief suggests the possibility Kovu was very young during either Scar's death or his real dad's but I'll suggest Scar's .
(3) Vitani and Kovu are most likely littermates. Scar is NOT Kovu's dad. His eyes aren't the same shade of green as Scar's. Also Kovu has a completely different balahibo tone and mane color. He only looks a little bit like Scar to arouse fear in Simba. Also it's stated sa pamamagitan ng nearly every Outsider that Scar isn't Kovu's father.
(4) In a deleted scene from the lion king. Scar wanted Nala as his queen. Not Zira which I can probably see why. Zira wasn't even in the Pride at that time. Meaning she probably had only recently come in just before Simba came back.
Reasons why Simba isn't her father either.
(1) Why would Zira EVER mate with Simba? She hates him. Also if Simba or Nala were Vitani's parents I think Zira would probably have killed her off instead. Plus you seen how wacko Zira is over Scar considering he doesn't pag-ibig her but you know.
(2) Incest. If Vitani were Simba's . Which she is not. Then considering her and Kovu are most likely littermates. That would mean Kovu is to. Which is the whole reason Scar isn't Kovu's father. So him and Kiara aren't related. There you have it Vitani's father is an outsider male.