do you think Bella should have had a baby sa pamamagitan ng Edward in Breaking Dawn

they did...

they do...

yeah, i do. because its what edward thought he couldnt give her- and he did.
the jacob/renesmee thing does my head in though, it really does. (:

"do you remember when we told charlie we were getting married? and he thought you were pregnant?"
"and he thought about shooting you", I guessed with a laugh. "admit it- for one second, he honestly considered it"
He didn't answer.
"what, Edward?"
"I just wish... well. I wish that he'd been right"
"gah" I gasped.
"more that there was some way he COULD have been. That we had that kind of potential. I HATE taking that away from u, too"
It took me a minute. "I know what I'm doing"
"how could you know that, bella? look at my mother. look at my sister. It's not as easy a sacrifice as you imagine"
"Esme and Rosalie get sa pamamagitan ng just fine. If it's a problem later, we can do what Esme did-we'll adopt."
He sighed, and then his voice was fierce. "It's not right! I don't want u to have to make sacrifices for me. I want to give u things, no take things away from u. I don't want to steal your future. If I were human-"....

Well, I think that this could answer your question, it's something that happen in the beginin of breaking down, and I think that was something sweet that meyer add this edward's wish in the book and I really pag-ibig it. Remember it's just ficcion.