What do you think the difference between shoujo ai and yuri and shounen ai and yaoi is?

A while ago, I came to understand that Shojo Ai (Girls Love) and Shounen Ai (Boys Love) were about same sex romance stories, while Yuri and Yaoi were similar but madami explicit and graphic in nature. But nowadays, I prefer to just drop the distinction and use the terms Yuri and Yaoi for any same-sex themed animes.

I'm noting that Media Blasters have a label called "Yuri Fan" (and might have one called Yaoi Fan). Most of these are hardly what I'd call explicit. presa Panic has only a limited amount of tagahanga service beyond an occasional kiss, for instance. And they don't have an "18+" rating. If those anime are Yuri, I can't imagine anything "less explicit" than them yet still same sex that they would be labeled as Shojo Ai instead. So I don't think the international anime industry is supporting the distinction between the terms. And then there's Yuru Yuri. It's got Yuri in the title, so I'm gonna call it a Yuri anime, even if it's mostly gag material and not really explicit, and even if they're just referring to "Lilly"s in the pamagat instead of Yuri's other meaning.

Maybe there's room to make a distinction between Shojo Ai/Shounen Ai and Yuri/Yaoi in the realm of manga, doujinshi, and tagahanga art, but in the realm of anime, I don't see any need to distinguish between the two. If there was a madami explicit yuri pamagat than normal, I'd just call it a yuri ecchi or yuri hentai.

There's probably no right or wrong answer to this, as they're terms that may have different meanings or connotations to different people in different contexts and evolve over time.
*
maybe i'm a little confused in that i've never actually seen a Shoujo Ai pamagat and all of the yuri I've seen are actually really yuri. just about any kind of perverted gag seems to be enough to count it as a yuri, even if the gags don't "cross the line". an actual shoujo ai pamagat would probably bore me. but i suppose trying to distinguish a yuri from a shoujo ai pamagat is really just as diffucult as trying to distinguish a romantic comedy from an ecchi.
ChadKumada posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
 ChadKumada posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Anime Sagot

pumpkinqueen said:
I don't know about anime and manga for it. But for myself, I call myself a Shoujo Ai and Shounen Ai tagahanga not a Yuri or Yaoi fan.

Because from what I have learned being in those fandoms. Yaoi and Yuri fans focus madami on the sexual side of the relationships.
Like, if an OVA doesn't have a sex scene, they aren't happy with it. Like I have seen "Awww, no sex? I want me some Yaoi!" and I'm like "You just got some 'Yaoi' this whole thing was about a homosexual relationship'. Sometimes you even see them complaining about doujinshis not having sexual scenes. When I'm sitting there thinking it was beautifully made and touching, I didn't even want to look at anything sexual.
Or there are other fans who want a lot of doujinshis for their pairings and stuff. Fanart and fanfictions for example.


Shounen Ai and Shoujo Ai fans, focus madami on the actual relationships. The beauty of them and not the sexual part. From what I have seen, we don't care about the sexual parts. We just want to see the relationships and see the pag-ibig and beauty.

You can actually a lot of times see the different in Yaoi and Shounen Ai fanart as well. Because in Yuri/Yaoi fanart, you can definietly tell there is a seme/uke stereotype going on. While with Shounen ai/Shoujo Ai you don't really see it.

Here, this is a confession I made about it.
select as best answer
 I don't know about anime and manga for it. But for myself, I call myself a Shoujo Ai and Shounen Ai tagahanga not a Yuri or Yaoi fan. Because from what I have learned being in those fandoms. Yaoi and Yuri fans focus madami on the sexual side of the relationships. Like, if an OVA doesn't have a sex scene, they aren't happy with it. Like I have seen "Awww, no sex? I want me some Yaoi!" and I'm like "You just got some 'Yaoi' this whole thing was about a homosexual relationship'. Sometimes you even see them complaining about doujinshis not having sexual scenes. When I'm sitting there thinking it was beautifully made and touching, I didn't even want to look at anything sexual. Or there are other fans who want a lot of doujinshis for their pairings and stuff. Fanart and fanfictions for example. Shounen Ai and Shoujo Ai fans, focus madami on the actual relationships. The beauty of them and not the sexual part. From what I have seen, we don't care about the sexual parts. We just want to see the relationships and see the pag-ibig and beauty. You can actually a lot of times see the different in Yaoi and Shounen Ai fanart as well. Because in Yuri/Yaoi fanart, you can definietly tell there is a seme/uke stereotype going on. While with Shounen ai/Shoujo Ai you don't really see it. Here, this is a confession I made about it.
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
bubblegum_kiss said:
I would say that the genres "yuri" and "yaoi" would be considered madami sexual and graphic as opposed to just romance with no sex... I guess.

Honestly I wish classifications weren't so confusing,because there are times when they'll just blend together... Like if a story is pure romance but has like a couple sex scenes in it, it's automatically not considered shonen ai/ shojo ai anymore. Which i think is weird because if it's still totally romance and stuff I don't really think it should be ibingiay a whole new genre.

*When I mention that I like the genres of shonen ai/ yaoi I just say I like BL cause it pretty much covers it and it's less confusing. Plus i like the way it sounds better.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
next question »