Autumns pet would be....
A dog(run bud!). A loyal dog that would do everything she tells it to do.
Bud's pet would be....
A goldfish. Then he can make it sprout legs and have an amazing world of gumball ripoff ark.
Tiff's pet would be....
A cat. Cats are perfect for someone that's "exceedingly cute"!
Jacob's pet would be...
A bird. He could train it to be target man's sidekick.