sagutin ng tanong na ito

walang tiyak na layunin Tanong

A tanong kind of inspired off a Black Mirror episode....

If you had the ability to click a button and find out how long a relationship would last, may that relationship be friendship, romatic, or familial, would you click the button?

SCENARIO A: If you click the button, you will have to click the button every time after that for every relationship.

SCENARIO B: You do not have to click the button again if you click it once and it will always be open to clicking.

State what you would do under both scenarios
 Riku114 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

walang tiyak na layunin Sagot

Mauserfan1910 said:
I wouldn't in either scinario. The future isn't real, there's no such thing as fate. Even if something theoretically tell me the future, that won't change the fact that I still have to give my marriage my all, or else the future might still be wrong.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
^My theory alligns with yours. Also, even if it was capability to be 100% correct, I wouldnt anyways since knowing such a deadline would do nothing madami than make the left over days horrid.
Riku114 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
wantadog said:
As of like two years ago, I would have sinabi neither cuz I don't believe in fate or destiny, but since then my nakakita on it have changed. For friendships and familial relationships, I'm kinda meh on it so I'd probably do Scenario B for those cuz I don't care about my family very much and I only have one true friend.

On romantic relationships tho...I have noticed I've become rather cynical towards the concept of pag-ibig in the last two years, taking on a "it'll screw you over if you let it" attitude so I would emphatically choose Scenario A cuz you can't get hurt or betrayed if you don't put any trust in anything.

I realize that's a shitty way of looking at it. I kinda feel bad cuz I used to be upbeat and optimistic about that kind of stuff but eh.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
My answer didn't really answer what I'd DO in both scenarios so much as which relationships I'd choose for each scenario
wantadog posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Rihanna312 said:
In scenario A I wouldn`t press it. It would be too boring to live life that way. I imagine that would mean that I can`t change future no matter how hard I tried and everything would play out exactly as the button has said.

In scenario B I guess I might use that button if it`d work for, let`s say, old frieds with whom I`ve drifted apart. I would like to know if it`s worth trying to renew the friendship or if they have changed so much that we couldn`t really ever be good mga kaibigan again.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
8theGreat said:
I'm having a hard time thinking of anything that could actually be gained sa pamamagitan ng knowing that information.

Presumably it's so you can gauge how much time/effort/trust/expectation to put into sinabi relationship, so you aren't horribly disappointing when it ends, but the length of time you know that person would be a really crappy way to try and calculate that.

The time alone wouldn't indicate the quality of the relationship in question. You can have short-lived relationships that were really good and you were glad to have still, or you can be in a horrible relationship for years and years that you hate being in.

Like, I would much rather be close mga kaibigan with someone that I only knew for like 3 months that still left a lasting, positive impression on me than be stuck married to someone I hate for 10+ years because I'm scared to death of being alone.

And if you just knew how long each of those relationships lasted, and based its entire merit on how long it was, you'd assume the friendship was shit but the marriage was awesome when really it was the opposite.

Consequently, you may put less stock in a relationship you know is only going to last a short while that you actually had a lot to gain from. You may put madami stock into someone that's going to drive you absolutely insane in the long run and in the end not be worth it.

And if you weren't going to use it as a way to decide which relationships weren't and were going to be worthwhile, what would you even do with that information? You could say that you can't be hurt if you know the relationship will end in 10 months, but is it really the length of time or the relationship ending that hurts? It's usually something else, something madami nuanced, that makes it hurt.
Not to mention that every time you see that person, you're going to have how long your relationship will last in the back of your head no matter what. That would suck, not to mention that it would kind of take away from the organic factor of building relationships.

The only time it would really be beneficial at all in any way would be if it told you that you were going to be in a relationship that you were really happy, but there comes a point in any relationship whether it be a friendship or a romance or a familial thing where you can kind of tell on your own.
And that's assuming things don't go maasim and you just stay together because its convenient or something which does happen.


There's really no point in that sort of thing when you really sit down and think about it. Relationships are nuanced.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
next question »