sagutin ng tanong na ito

Severus Snape Tanong

He did NOT pag-ibig Harry. People please see reason.

I've heard this so many times, and quite honestly, Its getting on my nerves. I know a lot of people agree (and disagree) with me, but I had to say this before my head exploded.

Severus Snape did not pag-ibig Harry Potter. (in any way. Sorry slashers :P )

Yes, I know, Severus loved Lily.
He hated James.
I know the basics, but Im looking past that.

I don't think Severus ever loved the boy because..

1. He looked exactly like James Potter, who was his worst enemy and the man who estola his beloved

2.Living proof that Lily loved someone else

3. To some extint, Harry was the reason his Mommy died

4.Severus was a reasonable man, but he held grudges, and some of them surpassed generations, and though he may have been able to see Lily in Harry sometimes, most of the time he only saw James.(because he DID constantly break rules)

I realize that he risked his own neck for harry, but I really think that it was only a guilt/love thing to sort of (im looking for a word here...)compensate? or repay Lily for the damage he did.

Thoughts? Arguments? Agreements?

 Misguided_Angel posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Severus Snape Sagot

dylin1 said:
It does make total sense, and I see exactly where you're coming from, but this is always going to be an unresolved matter. The love/hate/whatever relationship between Sev and Harry will always be a matter of opinion. I'd like to think that even though he had an immediate hate on for Harry, he may have felt compassion for the bravo little orphan. After all, Harry Nawawala just as much as Snape did, if not more. He Nawawala the chance at a family, a childhood, and the unconditional pag-ibig of a mother.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I see where you're coming from, too. :D
MrsEmmaPeel posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
thank you :)
dylin1 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I agree with you.There are other things to consider, like the fact he was a skilled occlumens so knew very well how to hide his true feelings from Harry (and everyone else).It was essential for him to keep Harry at a distance if he wanted to continue spying for the Order.It made sense to treat Harry like he did in class especially since a lot of Harry's Potions/DADA classmates were Slytherins with death eater fathers who can suspect Snape's true allegiance.I'm not saying Severus loved Harry,but he may have cared for him secretly, why would he be visibly devastated when he learned that Harry had to die in the end (the raising him like a pig for slaughter..) comment,that to me shows Severus did care for him, to some extent..
PiscesGeekyGirl posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Vixie79 said:
I absolutely agree with you.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Especially #2.
Vixie79 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
bri-marie said:
I agree with every single point. Every single thing Severus did was for Lily. LILY, not Harry. I don't think he hated Harry as much as he claimed, but he, in no way shape or form, held affectionate feelings for him.

And, can I just say, while we're on the subject of truth and lies:

Severus Snape is NOT Harry Potter's father!!

Sorry. But I keep seeing that pop up everywhere and it's driving me nuts!
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Really? WOW! LOL!
Vixie79 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
it still would have been cool if he was harrys father.
lovewar66 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I totally agree.
MrsEmmaPeel posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Nightmare15 said:
Im not going to say that he hated Harry, but he DID NOT pag-ibig HIM so yep, I agree.


select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
gloriassainteye said:
I fully agree and want to add that Lily loved Harry and I believe Severus would've been jealous of that love, despite the fact it was a maternal love. It was her pag-ibig that kept Harry alive, pag-ibig that should've belonged to Severus. *long, sad sigh*
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
I don't think Severus was *that* shallow or petty.
BlackHound posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
I don't think Sev would be that swallow. He would only be jealous of the pag-ibig Lily gave to James.
MrsEmmaPeel posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
LadyNottingham said:
I fully agree with you too.

Severus made it quite clear when Dumbledore asked if he had grown to care for the boy. "Him ?" and then we have the touching scene which reveals Severus' patronus is a doe - the very same doe that helped Harry to retrieve the Sword of Gryffindor, the same patronus as Lily's. "After all these years ?" - "Always."

I think that Severus was even madami mapait over Harry because he probably thought that the boy might have been his son IF he had not botched it all up with Lily. She would have become his wife, maybe, and they would have ended up as a family.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
lovewar66 said:
SEVERUS DID NOT pag-ibig HARRY, HE CARED ONLY SOME TIMES CUZ LILY, HARRY LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE JAMES EXCEPT THE EYES. MA HAD IT RIGHT LILY POTTER DIED CUZ OF HARRY,SYBIL,DUMBLEDOR, AND TOM RIDDLE. SO HE SHOULD HAVE TH RIGHT TO HATE THEM FOUR.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
No, Lily didn't die because of her son, or the seer, or the Elder Mage. She died, ultimately because of the choice Tom Riddle made.
BlackHound posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
still he has the right to hate the mall.
lovewar66 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Yeah, it might have been, but it was Voldemort himself who made Harry the Chosen One.
BlackHound posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
forsnape said:
I absolutely agree with you.

Besides all of the reasons you list,I think even if Harry was not James son,he was not that kind of student(or people) Snape would like.

He thought Harry possessed little magic talent,but was lazy and arrogant,full of the shortcomings he disliked,just as he disliked James.

But I dont think Snape hated Harry,he just Disliked Harry.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
MrsEmmaPeel said:
I agree.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Poseidon3 said:
Completely agree with you! He showed so himself in Dumbledore's office in the Pensieve.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
snapeinmymind said:
I see it this way too: no love!
But I'm speaking only of the movie-Snape. He did not pag-ibig Harry. But he also did not hate him.
He (Alan) never showed me hate when he looked at Harry. Sorry!
What I see is disappointment, frustration, sadness... But not hate or love.
I see, that Snape would have wanted to shout at Harry for all the trouble he had done. But this would have been against his nature. He also would have challenged him, but he was to controlled...He was his teacher! And Harry showed absolutely no respect (in my opinion).
I think, there was only one moment, when the movie-Snape - nearly - Nawawala his control: when he grabbed Harry at his magsuot ng bata (don't know the right words here) in the order of the phoenix.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
AbbieCoast said:
I agree with everything, except for the part that he saw Harry sometimes. He only did twice: MAYBE in Harry's first taon when he was staring and thinking, but DEFINETELY near his death when his last words are "look... at... me..."

But no he did not pag-ibig Harry. He just... doesn't pag-ibig a lot of people...
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
next question »