Amerikano Idolo
add a link
American Idol: David Cook Versus David Archuleta
American Idol: David Cook Versus David Archuleta
Both Davids are insanely talented (perhaps the best talent we've seen on AI since Kelly Clarkson back in the day) and yet remain wildly different, both on screen and off.
|
David Cook has shown more improvement, week over week, than Archuleta, but he still doesn't have anything that would impress me enough to buy an album.
The only two I'm impressed enough by to consider buying an album as of this week are Carly Smithson for the women and Michael Johns for the guys...and Michael's come from the back of the pack in the final stretch, in my estimation. They both have demonstrated the raw talent sufficient for a good music producer to generate something really fine for a recording.
That said, at the moment I'm not sure that I'd go out of my way to see any of them live in concert (whereas, I'd drive 50 miles to see Amanda Overmyer perform). I have high hopes - with no real reason for that hope - that the remaining contestants' performances will improve into something watchable, as well as pleasing to the ear.
and i personally think that people are too nice and accepting of archuleta. he FORGOT the lyrics! i dont remember which song it was on now, perhaps it was during beatles night, but he FORGOT them. Several times. If anyone else had done that, he or she would have been destroyed, and simon would never have accepted it. i dont understand why people think he's so amazing.
and on a more personal opinon, i'm getting kind of tired of david a.'s inspirational "has such a great message" songs (evvvvvery weeeek)
I think he is very cute and he has a unique style. I’ll buy all his album, and DL all his songs.
David A. has a good voice but when he is singing , I don’t see a 17 year old , all I see is someone who has a nice voice, and I think he can sing but he needs more time to find himself first.
Of course, Im biased towards David Cook!!!!
David C, If you read these... Im so proud of you!! You have already made it!!!! Keep true to yourself.
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment