When Edward left Bella in the segundo book, did you think that she was going to be with Jacob forever of that she would be with Edward?

At the begining i thought so but later when alice came to see bella and then bella went with her to go save edward that kind of told you that they were going to get back together.

she couldn't live without Edward!!!:X

Bella and Edward Forever:X

he's the hero of the book of course edward would come back.

jacob

of course i knew she was going to be with Edward again. There were 2 madami books after that and Edward is the 2nd most important character in the book, and their connection was amazing and unforgetable. They were meant to be...

LOL! I knew there'd be madami to both relationships since there were still two madami books to read! ;-)~

If Bella would wind up with Jacob, there wouldn't have been any need for an entire first book detailing her relationship with Edward. If the first relationship was meant to be a failed one, the first few chapters of New Moon would have been enough to set it up.