sagutin ng tanong na ito

Harry Potter Tanong

Why does everyone pag-ibig Snape? And hate Ginny? I didn't read the books..

*
Like others have said, you should read the books! They're wonderful and if you liked the pelikula you'll be in for a fantastic treat!
jameswilson posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
snape is a very good wizard.all he do is for harry potter. he loves harry bacause of lily potter.
mikeepotter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
youre correct!
mikeepotter posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
 chopilichi posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Harry Potter Sagot

maryksand said:
Snape is a rather contradictive character (which is good), that's why there are so many opinions about him. Personally, I like the way he is written but never in million years would I buy him as this "tragic hero". His one-sided pag-ibig for Lily doesn't make him one. He betrayed her trust, he went to buddy up with death eators, he was ok with her son and husband being murdered only if she survives - all he cared about was his obsession with her. He bullied her son for years. Yes, James bullied him in high school, but James matured and grew out of it and went out as a hero at 21. Snape bullied kids as a grown up man. I'm sorry, but no. Not heroic, not romantic and just pathetic. As a dark character I liked him, but "the bravest man Harry has ever known"? How about no?

I was completelly irrelevent to Ginny before book 6 when she suddenly became a bitchy Mary Sue out of a blue. Insulting your sister in law sa pamamagitan ng calling her "phlegm" instead of Flear is not funny. And she is suddenly good at everything including Quiddich (of course to fit into Potter's dream girl concept), even though we never saw her ipinapakita any interest in it before and then we where suddenly introduced to the information that she used to steal broomsticks from Fred and George when she was younger. And of course all the boys are drooling over her. All of it was so forced and contrived. I don't even hate her, I hate how she was shoved down our throats as a Mary Sue and was sold as a perfect girl for Harry.

select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
This is the exact reason I don't like Snape.
D_J267 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
jameswilson said:
I'll put in my two cents here. I don't have anything against Ginny at all. I haven't enjoyed the movies. I've read all the books at least five times and pag-ibig them.

Snape is my paborito character because he is one of the most dynamic and interesting. His best childhood friend was Lily - he loved her and she truly cared for him. Though they drifted apart and he became a death eater, he never forgot her. I just pag-ibig to think about the ways Harry affects him and the dilemma he must have experienced every time he saw Harry. He was a tortured, sad soul but somehow still managed to let pag-ibig ultimately decide his fate.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
50 points to whatever House you're in.
BlackHound posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
:]
jameswilson posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
bri-marie said:
Well, first off, not everyone likes/loves Snape and dislikes/hates Ginny.

Everyone has their own reasons for liking and disliking a character. Some like Severus because he's a complex character. Some like him because his back story was touching. Some like him for his humor. Some for his flaws. Others (like myself) can relate to him. And still others (like myself) like him for a combination of all those things.

I, personally, agree with what maryksand sinabi about Ginny. But, over all, the same goes for Ginny as it does for Snape: everyone has their own reasons for feeling the way they do.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
lolibarbie said:
I don't pag-ibig Snape, but I do hate Ginny. Well, I don't hate her, I just dislike her a lot because I just feel she is just so walang tiyak na layunin as a character.

But of course, I haven't read the books either.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
rere14 said:
i do like snape and ginny

with snape i think people rather felt guilty, there was so much hate towards him before they realize what's the reason of his behavior, and I think so many people pag-ibig the relationship between snape and lily, after book 7 he became this complex character that just simply blow people away

with ginny, i have to say i rather pag-ibig her in books, in the movie the reason ginny not that loveable I think because the screenwriter. JK rowling pag-ibig ginny, in the other hand Steve Kloves dislike her and openly sinabi that he's in harry/hermione team,for me there's so many amazing moment in HBD that was not portrait in the movie.

personally I pag-ibig ginny, she still can be herself even when chamber of secret happened, that moment i always think is when she practically deprived of her childhood, I think it's amazing she still can laugh and fight after that, she's a survivor, and I don't think she's perfect, she reckless, hot headed and sometimes rude, but there's no character in harry potter that I think is completely perfect, that was one of the things I pag-ibig about harry potter series.

but the main reason i pag-ibig ginny, is because I'm like Hermione, I'm bookworm, one of my fav place in my school was the aklatan and I also madami serious than people around me, and ginny reminds me of my best friend, my first friend ever actually,she one of most popular girl in my school,and just like ginny who befriend with Luna and Hermione, she became my friend without seeing the different between us. I felt that character like her who never judge a person sa pamamagitan ng her/his appearance was rare and also amazing.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
twilighter4evr said:
I didn't like Severus untill I read HBP & DH then I understood madami of who he is and why he had to be the way he was. I don't think he didn't care about Harry especially when Dumbledore mga panipi "Don't tell me know that you have feelings for the boy?" he responds with "Always" it may have only been for his pag-ibig for Lily that he did care for him but that doesn't matter to me...I don't hate Ginny she's good to me =)
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
cb0104 said:
I pag-ibig Snape when I read the Order of the Phoenix because a chapter was about how Snape was bullied horribly sa pamamagitan ng James (Harry father) merely because it was entertaining to James. So I felt bad. Then in the deathly Hallows I completely fell in pag-ibig with Snape because he has been looking over Harry since Harrys first taon and he did this because he was in pag-ibig with Harrys mom, Lily. He has always been in pag-ibig with her since they were both 11 or so. Which I found very touching because this big scary guy turns out to be a lovestruck teddybear.

I don't know why people hate Ginny because I pag-ibig her she's a sweet strong girl. She grew up with with 6 older brothers and I think that proves shes not a pris or something like that. So I don't absolutely pag-ibig her but she's an alright girl
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
BlackHound said:
Since you haven't read the books, no amount of explanation or opinions from other people is going to help you answer these questions. You really have to figure the stuff out for yourself.


Ginny: I pag-ibig Ginny Weasley and wish I'd had a friend like her when I was that age, an eternity ago. I couldn't care less about what other people think about her.

Severus Snape: I could tell you what I think about him and how I feel about him, and what I think about some of the crap people say about him (not that anyone else cares), but since you haven't read the books, I would probably just confuse you, and possibly irritate the Snape-haters.

Just do yourself a favor and read the books. ;)
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
TheFey21 said:
Never really liked both of them.

Ginny became Super!Ginny. Since book 1 I never liked her character.

Snape hmm.. his backstory was sad but still didn't make me pag-ibig his character.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
delamico said:
Read the books and you'll understand. Or not. Why the hell is Snape the hero?
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
BeckyJPM said:
First off, I strongly recommend you read the books. If you like the films, you will honestly pag-ibig the books, which in my opinion go into so much madami detail and are 100 times funnier, scarier and are just plain brilliant.
I think people pag-ibig Snape because he's been through so much. It's kind of pity love, really, because pretty much everyone hated him for so long, because he seemed like a cruel, heartless human being. But then we find out that he has a human side in his loving Lily, and we immediately feel sorry for him, and admire him for his bravery in defying Voldemort, his unwavering pag-ibig for Lily and his loyalty to Dumbledore.
I don't know if everyone hates Ginny. I don't particularly mind her in the books, but I can't stand her in the films because there's no depth to her. In the books she's funnier and feistier, madami like a female Fred or George, which some people find annoying.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
ecpjll said:
go read the books-don't ask us. You're just cheating yourself out of an amazing experience if you don't read them. The pelikula would suck and would be extremely hard to understand without pagbaba the books first.Plus why take our word for it? Don't you want to form your own opinion on the characters true natures'? Quit being so lazy and get off your asno and read the books! haha!
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
*
Well sorry if I didn't read the books, I've read other books, and just because I didn't read HP doesn't mean I'm lazy, or I don't understand the movies. I do understand them, I just didn't get why Snape won everything and everyone talked about how cute he is etc. If you won't help to solve my question, just don't answer.
chopilichi posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
*
Well why are you contradicting yourself again? If you don't get why Snape won everything and people think he's cute, etc, and you still don't want to read the books to find out, how will you find out? Or, do you want someone to write down an entire 100-page summary of the book for you?
maniks posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
Sandfire_Paiger said:
Read the books or watch the Deathly Hallows part 2 to know why Snape is awesome (I recommend books). I have no idea why people hate Ginny so much. :/
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
next question »