I love the fact that he finally believed in the island, in fate and all these stuff Locke was trying to get him in!
But now he's so different... He wants to erase the past.. :S

I love both ;p But yeah, there is something in old Jack that I fall in love with...

He wants to erase the past
Well this is the part when I agree with New Jack. If I were him I would do the same thing ;/

I hate the new Jack. Seriously!! :)

That was actually really, really tough!

On the one hand I of course love the old Jack, stubborn but loveable lol. But then now... I know that it's wrong that he wants to erase everyone's past, but in Jack's opinion he's doing it for the wellbeing of everyone. We know that if the plane lands safely a lot of bad things still happen, but I think in Jack's point of view the bad things on the island kinda overshadow the bad stuff that will happen even if 815 does land.

So... I love Jack no matter what really! lol

I also love the old doctor-Jack, not the new workman-Jack! The one who was the leader and a hero.♥ The new Jack's plan to erase the past sucks a lot. lol

If I were him I would do the same thing
Really? :O
You'd want Kate in jail, Claire give the baby away, Sun & Jin not happy together, Rose dead and Bernard unhappy, Desmond still in the hatch, Hurley 'cursed', Juliet living with the others, Locke in a wheelchair, 'bad' & alone Sawyer, Charlie still a junky and all these couples & friendships NEVER EXIST!?

in Jack's point of view the bad things on the island kinda overshadow the bad stuff that will happen even if 815 does land
I know! But this plan sucks:P

ofc I still love him too♥

Yes. Because
1. I belive that "People that are meant to be together always find their way in the end".
2. Jack's life on the island and off the island never was really happy. Yes, he had great time with Kate at some point, but he was always missing something. He couldn't forget people on the island. So, at his point of view, his life would be much easier without this wall people. Aslo Charlie, Boone, Locke, Charlotte, Daniel, Ana Lucia, Eko ... would be still alive. Beside, did Jack know that Claire was going to give her baby away or about Sun\Jin problems or Locke on the wheelchair? Also Desmond wouldn't be in hatch 'couse there is no hatch after explosion....

So, yes, if I were him and know same things he knows I would do the same thing ..

That's when I fell in love with him. The Pilot.
But I love him anyways. <3

Em just made so much easier for me.I will only agree with her!lol
and Jack is always love=P

I don't like the new Jack!
I loved the old one!

Sylwia I see your point of view..
And I don't blame Jack! <3
Btw he knew about Claire & baby.
But, for example, I prefer a dead Charlie than an unhappy junky who has never loved or been loved from Claire... or met all those awesome ppl [like Hurley] & lived some of the best moments of his life with them...♥

^^ I agree with the last bit of your comment there Maria... I mean Charlie's #1 moment in his entire life was meeting Claire, so :/

Old Jack! The Jack that fought for what he believed, that stand for the ones he care <3

I continue to love, and I understand the growth of his character because it totally makes sense... But he's so bitter and sad, and letting things happen when in his old self made things happen! His character lost a big part of the essence of course... but the change is legitime and makes sense and as I said I still love him as much as before!♥

And I agree with Sylwia, if I was in his place I would probably do the same... He wants to spare a lot of suffer and deaths... so I don't think his plan sucks... Actually it's really smart!

♥ I love both !!!
I dot'know what, but I love more the old Jack.

..neither..i've never really liked Jack.

I love any kind of Jack as long as its Jack.

Okay, probably it's just me but I think the new Jack is stronger, he has changed in a good way.

Though, I prefer both just because I love him :)

This is a tough choice for me, cause while the old Jack has at times annoyed me more then new Jack has. I disagree with his whole "change the past" thing and something about him just annoys me more then normal.

I love both.

I love the old Doctor Jack more, too. I agree with lost_Skater totally! He was too "right" and annoyed many fans, but he was a hero and the leader. I love him also now, but the new Jack has lost something. Will he change ? more to the old jack?

I love Jack period.

new Jack annoys me sometimes

i hate the new fate and destiny no time for love crappy jack! sorry but if i were kate i would have punched him in the face a bunch of times and then tell him 3 things
1. what the hell are you doing? put that bomb down go find kate and make out with her! she wants you man!
2. your hair looks realy bad! get a haircut for god sake!
3. stop acting like lock! u CANT! be lock ! you're jack! be that!