or maybe the first jeyton. but this one i was just bawling

the most random break up ever! it didnt even make sence! i honestly think the writers just did a choppy job at ending them to make room for LP. but yet at the same time it was the most heartbraking, shocking and terrible breakup on the show, ohh how i wish it never happened lol.

VERY DRAMATIC!!!! I was like WTF? I was too busy trying to process Jamie drowning and Naley arguing inside and when they came out and saved him...I didn't expect her to say a divorce..so that was the most shocking out of the all them.
I would choose Leyton's next cause it was dramatic cause we already know they are no longer together but what made that happen...?I was not shocked with Peyton saying that they should wait cause I was on her side with this.She had a really good reason to not get engaged at that point in their lives but I was surprised to see Lucas's reaction...but then again he has sorta done the whole" he wants to be with her and for some reason she's either scared,unsure or not ready and he then closes up!"(season 1 remember?)
so with is is sorta repetition with Lucas made it less surprising compared to Naley;s which was like "your son just almost drowned..its not really the best time to make that decision" But I have to say I loved Naley's drama...it was more interesting then the one they had during season 7

very shocking...when haley asked for a divorce i was like WTF?!!?

Well, If i was asking for the most saddest my answer would be diffrent. Obviously it would be based on my favorite couple, but I have to admit this was the most shocking I did not see it at all. I was like wait why is Peyton coming back to Tree Hill. Then when I saw the flashbacks I was like wow I did not expect that!

Selfish, unforgiving Haley. Jamie should have drowned that day.

By the way Brooke and Felix = Belix ummm or Frooke.

I never thought Haley of all people would leave her husband to go on tour...with another guy!

This one and the 2nd one of Leyton.

its was not nice and i really dont like Leyton# 2- Peyton refuses Lucas's proposal either.

This one was horrible..I was crying and of course the 2nd of Leyton

Naley that season was dead on, and good drama. The others were HS aged drama.

& Haley asking for divorce.

I honestly didn't see this one coming, I just don't understand why they would bring Jeyton back together only to rip them apart two seconds later, what was the point of even giving fans hope?

this was the most tramatic for me ! I was sooo sad, and cried like non-stop
but as far as shocking goes, i thought Leyton had finally figured out tht they loved eachother in season 4, so when she refused his proposal tht was shocking i guess

i thought peyton woulda learnt by then that its always lucas and peyton<3
i really never expected her to say no:0
so glad they marry in the end :)(L)