The Lexicon says that he's been cast.

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He is not even handsome!

eh, i was thinking that carlisle would be hotter. peter just kind of has a creepy face to me

i kinda like him but he needs blond hair!

I'm going to give him a chance. With the right hair and make-up, he'll probably be able to pull it off... I hope.

im sure hollywood can make him look the part, but hes just not what i imagined at all. hopefully it works out tho....

I was a little surprised at first, but I think he's gorgeous. I'm more concerned with acting than the hair color, so I think he will make a good Carlisle

i think he will do a good job

Sure iv nevr heard ov him b4.... but we'll c

Dude!! Seriously u guys!! they oviously die their hair the color that the charecters hair is supposed 2 be!!! & they also use Contacts for their eyes : or special affects!...i think he'll do!

i can see him playing carlisle it can happen

He's starting to grow on me, I think he'll do a fine job. He wasn't what I had expected at first, but he's really growing on me. I'm sure Peter will do a fine job as Carlisle.

i think he looks the best in the 1st cullen family photo. in his like photostils and stuff, he doesnt look like carlisle. im glad with the outcome! he's totally grown on me.

He will do a great job, though not what i really had in mind...but o well!

He'll do good i guess

I am sure it will work in the end but carlisle is suppose to be the head the family the father figure and of all the stuff I have seen him in he plays a goof ball or a playa so I just can't see him in that kind of role.

uh yummy! =D

If he dyes his hair. I'd like it to be accurate. Carlisle is blonde :)

omg.
this picture is fricken sexyy.

Drool.
Hes Soo Fit ;)

OMG! He's so SEXY! Damnit, he HAD to be married D=!

SO HOT!!!! OMG OMG OMG!

I love him, he's so hot and adorable, OMG did i mension he's hot :D LOL, he's sexy, he's every girls dream :D LOL

He did a good job! He makes one SEXY vampire doctor! XD

He's perfect. :)

Sexy beast