sagutin ng tanong na ito

Harry Potter Tanong

Thestrals and Harry

Okay why can't Harry see Thestrals before? First I thought shouldnt he be able to see them because of his parents deaths but then I though he might not have seen them die properly but at the end of 4th taon he still calls the carriages 'horseless'. Only when he enters 5th taon does he see them! Can anyone think of a reason why this is? Thanks
 TMR-RIP-2-5-98 posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas
next question »

Harry Potter Sagot

bri-marie said:
When was too young to understand what had happened when his parents died.

Cedric's death hadn't hit him yet. He saw Cedric die, and then right after fight Voldemort, found out a person/teacher he trusted greatly had been trying to kill him, and was sent tahanan in less than a week. It was too much for him to process and, since he hadn't processed and come to terms with Cedric's death, he wasn't able to see the Thestrals.

EDIT: For the people who keep insisting that JK hasn't covered this - link was taken directly from her site.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
emilykuru said:
IT maybe a mistake of jkr,

but when i think madami clearly, i think, maybe it was because his mind was full of confusion that he couldnt focus much on the reality that he had seen cedric die. but during the holidays, he spent nights dreaming of cedric and that fact registered hard in his mind. thats why he could see thestrals from then on. maybe this is the explanation.but we dont know for sure-do we? : )
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
CruciatusCRUCIO said:
That occured to me when I was pagbaba OoTP. This is a mistake made sa pamamagitan ng JKR!!!!
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
Klug said:
I believe that Harry could not see the thestrals when he first came to Hogwarts (although he should have due to witnessing the killing of his mother) because he was so young when those killings took place, he could not remember fully, which would cause him to not see the thestrals. While this issue was never adressed sa pamamagitan ng J.K.R. (as far as I know), I don't think it was a mistake.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
LadyNottingham said:
In order to see Thestrals, one has to understand what death means. Obviously, an infant could not. Like Bri said, Harry did not have the time to understand Cedric's death but I suppose he had a lot of time during Summer to process it and grasp the meaning of all of it before going back to school - hence his ability to see them when entering 5th year.
select as best answer
posted sa loob ng isang taon na ang nakalipas 
next question »